Games Workshop notes that space fascism would be bad

[TheSword]

To be fair to them. The warp, witches, daemons and everything scary you ever thought was under your bed as a child IS real and IS coming to get you. It’s an extreme threat that has generated an equally extreme reaction. Hence the distopia being plausible.

What is really clever is that you can see where the good intentions got twisted by mankind’s sins and the sheer logistical nightmare of ruling a galaxy. It’s a setting where Mankind’s grasp definitely has exceeded its reach.

I really like when books like Dan Abnetts show good folks in this setting, doing their best in bad circumstances. They show how things could have been different.

 

[Blue Orange]

Yeah, people forget that Spain only transitioned to a democracy in 1982. Still, even the Spanish at least try to make a distinction between Spanish Fascism (still very very bad) and Nazism. Even Franco wasn't insane enough to ally with Nazi Germany in WW2.

Minor point, but the Finns allied (ah, excuse me, were 'co-belligerents') with the Nazis in WW2 to keep out the Russians. They remained democratic, didn't persecute their (small, native) Jewish minority, and a few Jewish Finnish soldiers were actually awarded German medals (which they declined). Alliances in a big war can have less to do with ideology than national interest.

Going just off Wikipedia, Franco killed something like 15K-50K political opponents after winning; executions carried out by the nationalists (White Terror) were about 50K-200K whereas those by the republicans (Red Terror) were about 38K-72K. (Nasty business, civil war...)

Most likely he figured Germany, Italy, and Japan weren't going to beat the USSR, USA, and UK, and chose accordingly.

 

[Snarf Zagyg]

On the one hand, this shouldn't be necessary.

On the other hand, there are still people who don't understand that the movie Starship Troopers is mocking fascism.

So ... there's that.

 

[Jfdlsjfd]

On the other hand, there are still people who don't understand that the movie Starship Troopers is mocking fascism.

My first reflex was to say "Really?!?" because it's an obvious mockery of fascism and imperialism. But I guess it can be lost to some... However I don't think it's the exact same thing. I mean, the Starship Trooper world government could be replaced by another form of government and still function. It's totally possible that it would even help the situation with the Arachnid. On the other hand, the IoM is bad, but there is little alternative possible given the context and basically, if you're a "good guy", you'll do your best to lessen the problem of the IoM but not actively oppose it.

 

[Staffan]

Speaking of the problems with the Imperium of Man, I thought this video was pretty fun:

 

[Alzrius]

Minor point, but the Finns allied (ah, excuse me, were 'co-belligerents') with the Nazis in WW2 to keep out the Russians. They remained democratic, didn't persecute their (small, native) Jewish minority, and a few Jewish Finnish soldiers were actually awarded German medals (which they declined). Alliances in a big war can have less to do with ideology than national interest.

For those wondering, this was the Continuation War, named as such because it took place only fifteen months after the end of the Winter War.

On a related trivia point: Lauri Törni was a Finnish officer in both wars and who later fought with the Nazis against the Soviets. He subsequently emigrated to the United States and joined the U.S. Army Special Forces, being subsequently killed in action in Vietnam; today, he remains the only person buried in Arlington National Cemetery who also held a rank in the Third Reich.

 

[Helldritch]

That they have to remind people of this is beyond me.

 

[GMMichael]

Still, let's be honest. There's a certain part of a lot of us that wants to be evil and militaristic and destroy the enemy. It's the reason we have sports leagues (though I'm told those get violent sometimes in some countries...) and shooter video games. Better we do it with Warhammer minis than in reality, and there are no real Eldar, Orks, or Daemons who might get targeted.

I hear that some Orks are demanding proper representation in RPGs. And yes, there is that certain part...

This move from Games Workshop appears to be taking cues from people already within the community who don’t want to play games with fascists.

I wonder how strict GW (letters which already hint at fascism) will be about their policy, given how many "fascists" seem to be out there these days. Somehow, I doubt many of them are gamers.

 

[Blue Orange]

I hear that some Orks are demanding proper representation in RPGs. And yes, there is that certain part...

I wonder how strict GW (letters which already hint at fascism) will be about their policy, given how many "fascists" seem to be out there these days. Somehow, I doubt many of them are gamers.

Yes. Now I'd never call a real person an 'Ork' (kinda validates the stereotypes you're alluding to) but there were enough people who felt orcs hewed close enough to stereotypes that Wizards and others started changing the depiction of orcs. (Tolkien himself seemed to have realized the implications halfway through and started to back away from them.)

But I don't think human tribalism is going to go away. If orcs don't work, make it bugs or lizards or something recognizably nonhuman, or humanize both sides so you're making a more tragic war story. I'm hardly the expert here though.

GW hints at fascism? Well, there seem to be actual fascists on video game boards (source: I have been to RPG Codex), but most of the tabletop gaming crowd seems to lean left. (Even the RPG Pundit boots actual Nazis from his forum from what I can tell.) Not sure why this is.

 

[Vince_Snetterton]

This is as far into RL politics I will go, but even though WH and just about any dystopian world setting (the word dystopian might be a clue) are meant to be purely fantasy, perhaps cautionary tales (if the writer is really clever), RL is indeed heading down that path. I was reading an article (think it was Bloomberg) where the point was made that Musk now has more relative wealth that Carnegie did, before Standard Oil was broken up, and Carnegie started giving it all away. One only has to pick up a newspaper and read about the rise of authoritarianism across the planet.

It is not at all unreasonable to suggest that something along the lines of the Dune political system with House Musk, House Apple, House Bezos, et al will run humanity in the future. That is certainly a fascism-adjacent reality.