1. Robin Hood
Mr. Hood does a lot more for the people, and doesn't strike me as being as sketchy as Indiana Jones is at times. Plus, what kind of a loser uses a whip?
2. Batman
If it was Luke from the EU, then I'd vote him in without hesitation. But movie Luke just ain't that special.
3. Han Solo
Gandalf isn't really much of a hero. He is a Maia of the Valar, and his purpose is to help others perform heroic deeds, which occasionally forces to him to reluctantly perform them as well.
4. Spider Man
I.Can't.Believe.Kirk.Made.It.So.Far.
Carry on,
-Talgian