Greatest Character Showdown Round 4 (Results IN)

[Yellow Sign]

1. Gollum
2. Captain Malcolm “Mal” Reynolds
3. Robin Hood
4. Sherlock Holmes
5. Tarzan
6. Indiana Jones
7. Batman
8. Captain Jack Sparrow

 

[Furtive Noise]

1. Gollum
2. Abstain... could never sit through an entire episode of either of their shows, bleh
3. Robin Hood
4. Holmes
5. Han
6. Jones
7. Batman
8. Obi-Wan

 

[Relique du Madde]

Look at it this way.. Jack Sparrow's lucky go personality is what made him beat out those he "battled against" since we know that in the backs of our minds that none of his opponents would really want to defeat him. Vader would most likely ignore him, Dr. Evil would hire him on as a hench person only to get annoyed with his "incompetance" and his ability to escape death, and Obi Wan let him be knowing that someone as reckless and darksided as JAck Sparrow can actually be used as an instrument of the light if handled correctly (Jack Sparrow is like a drunker more chaotic version of Han Solo).

 

[DonTadow]

1. Gollum
2. Captain Malcolm “Mal” Reynolds
3. Robin Hood
4. Sherlock Holmes
5. Han Solo
6. Yoda
7. Batman v
8. Captain Jack Sparrow

 

[Talgian]

Voting is closed. New bracket and results in the morning.

-Talgian

 

[Talgian]

Round 5 in a few minutes.

1. Gollum[11] vs. Odysseus[24]
2. Buffy Summers[14] vs. Captain Malcolm “Mal” Reynolds[18]
3. Gandalf[19] vs. Robin Hood[16]
4. Conan[21] vs. Sherlock Holmes[14]
5. Han Solo[27] vs. Tarzan[8]
6. Indiana Jones[21] vs. Yoda[14]
7. Batman[25] vs. Superman[11]
8. Captain Jack Sparrow[22] vs. Obi-Wan Kenobi[14]

-Talgian

 

[johnsemlak]

This is a fun poll, I just can't believe that the two characters in category 2 made it this far. Must have been in a soft bracket.

Note that both characters are creations of Joss Wheadon (sp?), who is definitely one of the most talented writers in today's TV sci-fi/fantasy market. So I"m not suprised at all two of his characters made it.