• Welcome to this new upgrade of the site. We are now on a totally different software platform. Many things will be different, and bugs are expected. Certain areas (like downloads and reviews) will take longer to import. As always, please use the Meta Forum for site queries or bug reports. Note that we (the mods and admins) are also learning the new software.
  • The RSS feed for the news page has changed. Use this link. The old one displays the forums, not the news.

5E [Guide] How to Win Fights and Intimidate People (Another Barbarian Primer)

FrogReaver

Explorer
Unfortunately I still haven't seen Ancestral Guardian at the table yet. Does Spirit Shield help enough to matter, or does it just leave your party with a few more unused Hit Dice at the end of the day?
Isn't that the goal of any character optimization and ranking - to leave the party with more unused hit dice at the end of the day?


This one I have to disagree. Frenzy barely exceeds Zealot's standard damage, and if you need it early on then you're nearly useless for non-combat encounters (skill checks) the rest of the day.
Maybe, but there's something to be said about a variant human GWM level 3 frenzy barbarian. Getting two attacks at level 3 with advantage that can do 2d6+15 damage each is spectacular.

Now I wouldn't rate it better than zealot offensively early, but with the right build and higher levels it's really not that far behind.
 

Frankie1969

Explorer
Isn't that the goal of any character optimization and ranking - to leave the party with more unused hit dice at the end of the day?
I see 4 main limiting factors on the adventuring day:

  1. encounter-limited: run out of adventure.
  2. time-limited: run out of day.
  3. offense-limited: run out of problem solving.
  4. defense-limited: run out of healing.
Spirit Shield's importance is how often it extends limit #4 and allows continued adventuring.

In my experience, #4 is already infrequent for mid level PCs (except Leeroy Jenkins types) and 2 or 3d6 per round doesn't seem like enough to reduce that probability much further. But I'd be glad to hear evidence that I'm mistaken.
 
Last edited:

FrogReaver

Explorer
I see 4 main limiting factors on the adventuring day:

  1. encounter-limited: run out of adventure.
  2. time-limited: run out of day.
  3. offense-limited: run out of problem solving.
  4. defense-limited: run out of healing.
Spirit Shield's importance is how often it extends limit #4 and allows continued adventuring.

In my experience, #4 is already infrequent for mid level PCs (except Leeroy Jenkins types) and 2 or 3d6 per round doesn't seem like enough to reduce that probability much further. But I'd be glad to hear evidence that I'm mistaken.
Offense and defense are two sides of the same coin. They both allow you to get through encounters you wouldn’t otherwise. However, in most cases what they both actually do is just make you end the day with more hot dice left - that’s because you rarely actually need that extra offense or defense to actually make it through the encounter or adventuring day.
 

Frankie1969

Explorer
Offense and defense are two sides of the same coin. They both allow you to get through encounters you wouldn’t otherwise. However, in most cases what they both actually do is just make you end the day with more hot dice left - that’s because you rarely actually need that extra offense or defense to actually make it through the encounter or adventuring day.
The two are heavily connected, and some of their resources are shared, but in the areas where they're different, you need both of them.

If your party has a bunch of nova strike capability, but you're injured, out of healing magic & hit dice, then attempting another combat is risky because a few unlucky hits could kill someone.
Likewise, if you have full HP and plenty of healing, but everyone's high level spell slots and other long rest abilities are used up, then another encounter is risky because there are many possible situations you won't be able to deal with.
Whereas if the party is mostly healthy, has a little healing reserve, and just a couple big guns left, then you're good to go on even if your overall resource level is lower than either of the previous scenarios.
 

FrogReaver

Explorer
The two are heavily connected, and some of their resources are shared, but in the areas where they're different, you need both of them.

If your party has a bunch of nova strike capability, but you're injured, out of healing magic & hit dice, then attempting another combat is risky because a few unlucky hits could kill someone.
Likewise, if you have full HP and plenty of healing, but everyone's high level spell slots and other long rest abilities are used up, then another encounter is risky because there are many possible situations you won't be able to deal with.
Whereas if the party is mostly healthy, has a little healing reserve, and just a couple big guns left, then you're good to go on even if your overall resource level is lower than either of the previous scenarios.
You seem to be adding additional options that no barbarians contributes. That’s bad analysis. All we have is 2 choices with the barbarian. Extra offense or extra defense. Both of those options have the same effect.
 

El_Jairo24

Villager
Unfortunately I still haven't seen Ancestral Guardian at the table yet. Does Spirit Shield help enough to matter, or does it just leave your party with a few more unused Hit Dice at the end of the day?
On the Spirit Shield: I like this very much as you can decide on which party member you are going to prevent damage.
Sure, in ideal situations, this varies little as damage is soaked by the tanky ones. But any damaged saved from the party member that doesn't have a healthy pool of HP left, means that they can stay in the fight, without needing some in combat healing (through potion or spell). Which has it's tactical benefits and for my build, it utilises the Reaction, which doesn't see much use until now.

It gives some more tactical flexibility.

FYI: I'm currently playing level 7 Barbarian. Of course you don't know how things would have been if Spirit shield didn't prevent as much damage, yet it feels good to be able to protect the more squishy ones.

This one I have to disagree. Frenzy barely exceeds Zealot's standard damage, and if you need it early on then you're nearly useless for non-combat encounters (skill checks) the rest of the day.
Well like the OP says in that thread: these are whiteroom comparisons of 21 rounds and have their average DPR printed. Which it doesn't take into account is the number of attacks which are made.
If both builds only target a big boss, than this is a sensible thing to compare. Yet there are things as multiple targets in combat, builds take feats, which allow to benefit more from certain scenario's.

The fact that the damage of a Berserker is spread over more attacks, is valuable as you can direct the damage to where it is needed. Because over kill, isn't taken into account to average DPR, this misrepresents things.

Nonetheless, the exhaustion limitation on the Frenzy Rage is poorly designed, that is true. It would have been better that it had a hard limit per long rest. Like 1 until level 9, 2 charges from 10-15 en 2 from level 16, or something along those lines. Or you could imagine, that they could use one more Frenzy than listed, and that one would cause Exhaustion.
But most of the time Berseker is more than fine, if you use it wisely. It's just not that shiny as it puts more Barbarian into your Barbarian so it seems bland at the surface, yet a Barbarian is something to be feared, so a more angry Barbarian,....
 

BookBarbarian

Expert Long Rester
Ixalan Vampires have an interesting interaction with Zealots rage beyond death. Since their bite restores hitpoints you could Rage, drop to 0 hp, fail three death saves, and as long as you grapple and bite something you before your Rage ends, you are just fine.

Aasimar also gets a free non-spell heal that can keep you from dying.

They are one hit wonders as far as builds go, but they are worth a mention.
 

Advertisement

Top