An observation relating to the Peter-is-dumb-and-should-have-fought-better argument:
I think that was one of the points of the 5 Years Gone story: we get to see a competent, kick-ass Peter Petrelli go to town with Future-Hiro. I think that was their way of saying "yeah, we know what this guy is capable of, he's just not there yet". We see future peter use several powers at once (he moves a beer mug with TK while invisible, for example). He makes decisive tactical choices in mid-combat, actually has a plan of action, and wears badass black clothes. This was all done to contrast his current persona, as a way for the writers to say "we're not stupid, we're writing him this way on purpose...".
I also think that Peter is not dead, though Nathan probably is. And I think we still see Future Peter come about. Instead of being guilty about blowing up NY City, he's guilty about blowing up his brother. It still gives him the edge his character needs to get his act together, but without, y'know...blowing up NY City.
In an unrelated tangent, I was talking about 5 Years Gone, and I referred to Matt's future self as "Dark Parkman". That had such a great ring to it, I pledged to use it whenever possible. Dark Parkman...kind of like Dark Phoenix, only with a beer-belly.
Eh. It made me laugh, anyway...
I think that was one of the points of the 5 Years Gone story: we get to see a competent, kick-ass Peter Petrelli go to town with Future-Hiro. I think that was their way of saying "yeah, we know what this guy is capable of, he's just not there yet". We see future peter use several powers at once (he moves a beer mug with TK while invisible, for example). He makes decisive tactical choices in mid-combat, actually has a plan of action, and wears badass black clothes. This was all done to contrast his current persona, as a way for the writers to say "we're not stupid, we're writing him this way on purpose...".
I also think that Peter is not dead, though Nathan probably is. And I think we still see Future Peter come about. Instead of being guilty about blowing up NY City, he's guilty about blowing up his brother. It still gives him the edge his character needs to get his act together, but without, y'know...blowing up NY City.
In an unrelated tangent, I was talking about 5 Years Gone, and I referred to Matt's future self as "Dark Parkman". That had such a great ring to it, I pledged to use it whenever possible. Dark Parkman...kind of like Dark Phoenix, only with a beer-belly.
Eh. It made me laugh, anyway...