Ancalagon
Dusty Dragon
The job I do involves a lot of "do these numbers make sense?" So I'm very good at quick "sanity check" estimations for a variety of things.
This can be difficult on GMs sometimes because, if it's a topic I'm vaguely familiar, I can quickly make an estimate for something. I won't be exact, but it can lead to ... erm... stark differences with the GM's quick guess, or "good for the game but wildly unrealistic" value.
For example
the GM: "the entire kingdom is behind you, this cannot fail!"
the party. "All right. You know what, a few hundred thousands GPs would be really a good way to solve this problem" (these are trusted individuals that would actually use the money and not just spend it"
the GM "uh, yes, we can provide you with 25 000 gp"
me "uuuh.... is the entire kingdom really behind us? You do realize that a country this size has, in D&D economics, a GDP in the range of over 200 million gp?"
GM stares
The GM: The area is a patch of pure ice in the middle of the wastelands somewhere. It will be very difficult to find.
Me: How big is this patch, roughly?
GM: a few miles?
Me: Should be spotable from far away
GM: the hills limits sight.
Me: Hey funky party wizard, how high up can you send that sensor?
Wizard: About a mile?
Me: How far can it see?
Wizard: as far as it has to, if it's important.
Me: math... Ok that gives us a sight radius of 143 km, provided that the planet has the same size as Earth"
GM stares
So... it's not good?
This can be difficult on GMs sometimes because, if it's a topic I'm vaguely familiar, I can quickly make an estimate for something. I won't be exact, but it can lead to ... erm... stark differences with the GM's quick guess, or "good for the game but wildly unrealistic" value.
For example
the GM: "the entire kingdom is behind you, this cannot fail!"
the party. "All right. You know what, a few hundred thousands GPs would be really a good way to solve this problem" (these are trusted individuals that would actually use the money and not just spend it"
the GM "uh, yes, we can provide you with 25 000 gp"
me "uuuh.... is the entire kingdom really behind us? You do realize that a country this size has, in D&D economics, a GDP in the range of over 200 million gp?"
GM stares
The GM: The area is a patch of pure ice in the middle of the wastelands somewhere. It will be very difficult to find.
Me: How big is this patch, roughly?
GM: a few miles?
Me: Should be spotable from far away
GM: the hills limits sight.
Me: Hey funky party wizard, how high up can you send that sensor?
Wizard: About a mile?
Me: How far can it see?
Wizard: as far as it has to, if it's important.
Me: math... Ok that gives us a sight radius of 143 km, provided that the planet has the same size as Earth"
GM stares
So... it's not good?

Last edited: