D&D General Iconic and Best Adventures in each Edition

[Eyes of Nine]

I think megadungeons are adventures that carry a lot of weight in the game, even if they’re not to everyone’s taste. There are many out there but I’d give my vote to Rappan Athuk as the best of them from 3e onwards.

I hadn't put any 3P items on my list, but if we are talking megadungeons, have to prop up Arden Vul - what a banger! Playing in it now, looking forward to reading it after this campaign ends...

 

[GuyBoy]

I hadn't put any 3P items on my list, but if we are talking megadungeons, have to prop up Arden Vul - what a banger! Playing in it now, looking forward to reading it after this campaign ends...

I’d never heard of Arden Vul till your post. Just had a look at it and Wow!
Looks awesome.

 

[Eyes of Nine]

I’d never heard of Arden Vul till your post. Just had a look at it and Wow!
Looks awesome.

Here's a thread here on ENW. Creator also participated (but otherwise pretty quiet here). (also a personal friend)

https://www.enworld.org/threads/the-halls-of-arden-vul-immense-megadungeon.669856/

 

[the Jester]

Pretending 4e doesn't exist yet again

Reavers of Harkenwold and Madness at Gardmore Abbey were the standouts.

Demon Queen's Enclave and King of the Trollhaunt Warrens were great, but the rest of the H/P/E modules were pretty terrible.

 

[John R Davis]

[3rd party in brackets]. Based on play experience/ memory

BECMI: X4/X5.

Ad&d: N1 [Starstone by Northern Sages].

3.X:Trilogy of Barrow king/sinister spire/ yuan ti [PF:Feast of Ravenmoor].

5th: Ghosts of Saltmarsh

 

[Zardnaar]

2E and 4E a but anemic.

Several adventures are iconic eg B2 but they're not really that good.

1E I6
B/X. X1, Nights Dark Terror, B4 Hidden City
2E Night Below, Mere of Dead Men, various Dungeon adventures.
3.0 Sunless Citadel
3.5. Age of Worms, Savage Tide
4E Madness GA, Harkenwold
5E CoS, ToA,