Ignore, it's over (But read Rav's post on page two, he's proud of it)

Does Postcount matter?

  • Yes, post count matters

    Votes: 15 41.7%
  • No, post count means nothing

    Votes: 21 58.3%

Status
Not open for further replies.
No, it means nothing.

Way back when Eric ran his site, it was discussed from time to time about giving titles to each poster. As the poster population grew, I imagine that titles would have to be automatically given upon certain numbers of posts. The general thinking was that such titles, and especially titles based on post count, would encourage the kind of negative poster competition seen on other sites, and would tend to discourage newbies from hanging around long.

Since the question was asked, I'll give my opinion, with no offense intended to anyone: imparting any kind of importance to post count is pointless, in my opinion. Quality is more important than quantity. There are plenty of posters whose posts I seek out who have relatively low post counts, and some with high post counts whose posts I often find myself automatically skipping over, due to what I perceive to have been a lack of relevant content in the average post by that poster (basically, a high signal-to-noise ratio). Again, no offense intended to anyone. I mean, I guess some would think my post count is high, but I don't think I'm particularly important because of it. I'm just my regular ol' dumb self.
 

log in or register to remove this ad

I certainly agree with you, ColonelHardisson, and I am somewhat glad that Meta posts no longer count in regard to post count. As I said, a high post count just shows a large number of posts made.
It doesn't say anything about the quality of the poster. He might be high quality, such as Crothian, or low quality, such as a ton of spam posts made. Titles or other goodies for post count are a bad idea, imho.
Such goodies should be reserved for those people who actually support the community, such as the Cummunity Supporters here at ENWorld, or the FAQ maintainers on the WotC boards.
 

i posted no because it doesn't matter in any meaningful or positive way.

it just indicates how much time you have to waste on this temporal suck of a website
 

plus even if postcounts mattered they've been reset, what three times at least since eric started the site.

and then look at a poster like sepulchrave, who has posted 100-something times yet his story hour has a huge following among posters who have wasted waaay more time browsing the boards then some care to admit.
 

Knight Otu said:

Well, then I'll say that it doesn't mean anything - except posting experience. (1 post equals 10 XPs ;))

Then I should be a lot closer to 2nd level than I am.... hehehehe.

I've stopped moaning now, I'm trying to write a Story Hour.
 

Hmmm, if postcount means truely nothing, Morrus & PC wouldn't stop postcount from Meta, so it must mean something... I don't know what, but something...
 





Status
Not open for further replies.
Remove ads

Top