Intelligent Item Alignment Change

fenzer

Librarian, Geologist, and Referee
Just a thought, but I was wondering if intelligent items could undergo an alignment change.

In the Unearthed Arcana the idea of Taint is offered, where a character can suffer the dark effects of his/her surrounding if exposed to them long enough. Could the same thing happen to an item?

Let's say an evil weapon was burried away in an holy area and left there for a long while. Would its ego be subject to its surroundings and subsequently be suseptable to a change of heart or alignment?

What do you think?
 

log in or register to remove this ad

fenzer said:
Just a thought, but I was wondering if intelligent items could undergo an alignment change.

In the Unearthed Arcana the idea of Taint is offered, where a character can suffer the dark effects of his/her surrounding if exposed to them long enough. Could the same thing happen to an item?

Let's say an evil weapon was burried away in an holy area and left there for a long while. Would its ego be subject to its surroundings and subsequently be suseptable to a change of heart or alignment?

What do you think?

It's a possibility.

It's definitely not accounted for in the RAW.

Actually, I'd personally interpret the RAW as not meaning to accomodate for such a thing, and I'd personally say that it would take something pretty special or unique to change an intelligent item's alignment... But I also really encourage Chaos (creativity) as opposed to Law (structure). And so, use your inner chaos to come up with a good support structure for such an idea. I don't see any reason not to. It sounds like a fabulous story in the making. MmMM Flavorful.
 

BoED allows for the redemtion of evil magic items but doesn't touch on intelligent ones. In such a case, it's like crafting a new item but the evil one acts in place of the gold. If it is simply a magical construct, the I suspect that it could be redeemed in the same way. It does say that certain items are irredeemable and can only be destroyed. These are mostly artifacts and relics.

Typically, flavor text in the campaigns I've been in have said that intelligent items are made so by transfering a soul or spirit into them. First judge by the personality of said weapon if it can be redeemed or not. If it can't, then it can't and can only be destroyed. If redemption is a possibility, then I'd say that it would take some active event to redeem it. Simply putting it in a good space probably wouldn't do it unless such a space would also do the same to a living creature. Even then I'd consider it harder than changing the alignment of a living creature as it's nature is probably set with magic. I'd say that it would take effort on the PCs side to role play with said item, find out why it is like it currently is, it's personality, and then take steps to correct these or show it the error of its ways by playing up to other bits of its personality. Sort of like getting Darth Vader to side against the emperor, you'd have to figure out which buttons to push and then push them hard. Then, for dramatic reasons, in an epiphany, the item would change alignment and possibly change or gain new good powers that would save the day at the most desparate time.

Another point, is that if you could get an itelligent item to change its alignment, then maybe it would lose what ever powers it had. It might still be able to use them but doing so would mean reverting back to the old alignment which the weapon would not want to do. Thus an intelligent Nine Lives Stealer who has turned good would still have the ability to steal lifes but would/could not use the power unless it was to change back to its evil alignment , a choice the sword would have to make.
 

Thanks for the replies.

Ya, this whole idea has sprung from a character idea I have, a redeemed bad guy, think anti-blackguard. I wanted him to retain his weapon, most likely an evil thing, from his life of evil but thought that unlikely. It would have to undergo a change as well. It does not have to be intelligent but I thought it would add flavor.

The character's transformation would have to be a pretty big deal. Using the BoED seemed like a good idea.

Any other suggestions would be appreciated.
 

Remove ads

Top