Just watched Narnia (Possible spoilers)

[Firebeetle]

the beavers and childern run in the the celebration after they have been turned into stone.

Yes, they are there. But that happens well before the coming of Christmas

 

[John Q. Mayhem]

Yes, they are there. But that happens well before the coming of Christmas

Well, it happens before the children see Father Christmas.

 

[Firebeetle]

Well, it happens before the children see Father Christmas.

*Sigh*, regardless, the scene from the book is not there. That scene is the Christmas merry makers being confronted by the witch who is chasing the children. Nor is there any indication that Christmas was involved beforehand, nor indication that the white witch was out and about in the neighborhood when she's in her castle in the next scene.

 

[Storm Raven]

*Sigh*, regardless, the scene from the book is not there. That scene is the Christmas merry makers being confronted by the witch who is chasing the children. Nor is there any indication that Christmas was involved beforehand, nor indication that the white witch was out and about in the neighborhood when she's in her castle in the next scene.

Well, no indication other than the fact that the animals have all been turned to stone.

 

[Firebeetle]

Well, no indication other than the fact that the animals have all been turned to stone.

Yes, but when did that happen? No indication that the queen has been made aware of the coming of Christmas yet in the following scenes. So did it just happen (no reason to believe so, could have been days ago) and is their being stone related to Christmas? No indication which means we should not presume what it means. They are simply a family of animals the witch has petrified for no apparent reason than being really, really mean (which she is, mind you.)

 

[John Q. Mayhem]

Hmmmm...now that I think about it, I believe the Fox mentions something about them trying to help Tumnus, and that he couldn't reach them in time to warn them.

 

[Storm Raven]

Yes, but when did that happen? No indication that the queen has been made aware of the coming of Christmas yet in the following scenes. So did it just happen (no reason to believe so, could have been days ago) and is their being stone related to Christmas? No indication which means we should not presume what it means. They are simply a family of animals the witch has petrified for no apparent reason than being really, really mean (which she is, mind you.)

I believe Mr. Beaver mentions something about having spoken with Badger quite recently.

 

[John Q. Mayhem]

I'm hoping the DVD will have an extended scene in the Professor's office and the Christmas scene.

 

[TanisFrey]

*Sigh*, regardless, the scene from the book is not there. That scene is the Christmas merry makers being confronted by the witch who is chasing the children. Nor is there any indication that Christmas was involved beforehand, nor indication that the white witch was out and about in the neighborhood when she's in her castle in the next scene.

However if you look carefully at the criters that are stone in that scene are sitting around a table looking like they got it in the middle of a celbration of some sort.

 

[David Howery]

well, I never did read the book, but I did see the movie yesterday... it's simply great... how could any D&D fan not like this movie, with it's minotaurs, giants, griffins, centaurs, etc... and Qui Gon Jin as Aslan...