Okay, reviewing the rules, it definitely seems like Serrana's best spot in vehicle combat is as the pilot, particularly in a craft that has pilot-operated weapons (like the Star Jewel). Taking her away from the primary pilot spot means that she can't use Vehicular Combat to negate an attack, and any pilot checks would be at Jade's +11 rather than Serrana's +16 (or +21, really, because Serrana would activate Fool's Luck immediately). And it looks like she can still be an effective gunner with a pilot-operated gun.
It's true that she'd also be a better dedicated gunner (on the second turret) than anyone else in the party, but since she doesn't have multiple attacks and strafing ground tragets with vehicle weapons hardly seems approriate for Jedi (even if Serrana suggests it might well be effective), the drop-off to the next-best gunner (Arro) is a lot smaller.
Basically, here's how we stack up as gunners on the Star Jewel (+2 int)...
Serrana, as pilot: ATK +8 (+4 BAB +2 Star Jewel's Int +2 Trained Pilot/pilot-operated weapon)
Serrana, as secondary gunner: ATK +6 (+4 BAB +2 Star Jewel's Int)
Jade, as pilot: ATK +5 (+5 BAB +2 Star Jewel's Int +2 Trained Pilot/pilot-operated weapon -4 non-proficient)
Jade, as secondary gunner: ATK +3 (+5 BAB +2 Star Jewel's Int -4 non-proficient)
Arro/Elan/Jarec/Nicolas, in either position: ATK +4 (+6 BAB +2 Star Jewel's Int -4 non-proficient)
Talesa, in either position: ATK +3 (+5 BAB +2 Star Jewel's Int -4 non-proficient)
Arro and Serrana have some ranged combat feats.
So I'd say we normally want Serrana as pilot and Arro as a gunner in a firefight.
It's true that she'd also be a better dedicated gunner (on the second turret) than anyone else in the party, but since she doesn't have multiple attacks and strafing ground tragets with vehicle weapons hardly seems approriate for Jedi (even if Serrana suggests it might well be effective), the drop-off to the next-best gunner (Arro) is a lot smaller.
Basically, here's how we stack up as gunners on the Star Jewel (+2 int)...
Serrana, as pilot: ATK +8 (+4 BAB +2 Star Jewel's Int +2 Trained Pilot/pilot-operated weapon)
Serrana, as secondary gunner: ATK +6 (+4 BAB +2 Star Jewel's Int)
Jade, as pilot: ATK +5 (+5 BAB +2 Star Jewel's Int +2 Trained Pilot/pilot-operated weapon -4 non-proficient)
Jade, as secondary gunner: ATK +3 (+5 BAB +2 Star Jewel's Int -4 non-proficient)
Arro/Elan/Jarec/Nicolas, in either position: ATK +4 (+6 BAB +2 Star Jewel's Int -4 non-proficient)
Talesa, in either position: ATK +3 (+5 BAB +2 Star Jewel's Int -4 non-proficient)
Arro and Serrana have some ranged combat feats.
So I'd say we normally want Serrana as pilot and Arro as a gunner in a firefight.
Last edited: