Maybe one thing I was looking at that I am not sure, it the scimitar I get.
Yes, it's support well my favored enemy power (giving +2 damage), but that would be better use with my bow, as I have more attack with it. Also, I don't think putting all on the same character will be the best thing. I would rather go with something thatw oudl give me a edge against any opponent, like the warhammer of shock, and gives the scimitar to a front liner who would more likely draw it when they will meet some monstrous hamnoids.
Also, what happen to the sceond short sword. Me and calenthang lost there short sword +1 and only Teleri gain one. Is the other lost in the limbo with Ayden?