Answers to ElectricDragon
I have thought about the duration, and you are correct. It should be concentration, but changing it to concentration requires a more detailed explaination to what the spell does, effectively age someone and state that there is no magic left after the spell has ended but yet the effect of it are permanent.
3 rounds/level is the CL cap I was talking about, and maybe it is necessary for the spell to be balanced.
As I mentioned in one of my above posts, a DM that allows ageing effects must also allow de-ageing effects. I will write a de-ageing spell as soons as Whispers of Old is finished.
You can only target on creature at the time with Whispers of Old. Do not ask me for a reasonable in game explaination, because I have none. The only thing I can think of is that what is whispered depends on who the target is. This also ensures that no one that hears the whispering are also affected.
The real explaination is to prevent senarios as the one you mention to occur.
I am actually working on a spell that will be able to bring back people whom have died of natural causes. It will be based on a host body concept.
The vocal loss is not that bad a flavor element. How about: The words whispered are so ancient and hard to pronouce that for each round the spell is active the caster loses his voice for one round afterwards.
Finally I have a question for you, since you seem to be quite experienced when it comes to balancing spells. Should you be able to use Whispers of Old via Scry through the use of Message?
ElectricDragon said:Your spell: Whispers of Old should have a duration of Concentration as written instead of Instantaneous; but I suggest limiting the duration to: 3 rounds/level (D).
Something like this:
Duration: Concentration (up to 3 rounds/level) (D)
I have thought about the duration, and you are correct. It should be concentration, but changing it to concentration requires a more detailed explaination to what the spell does, effectively age someone and state that there is no magic left after the spell has ended but yet the effect of it are permanent.
3 rounds/level is the CL cap I was talking about, and maybe it is necessary for the spell to be balanced.
ElectricDragon said:Limited wish used to age its caster 3 years and Wish 10 years. In 2e and earlier, potions of longevity conferred 1d12 years back to their drinker, and potions of youth gave less. If aging effects are to be used in your game; you should also have some easy method of reversing them (like those potions).
As I mentioned in one of my above posts, a DM that allows ageing effects must also allow de-ageing effects. I will write a de-ageing spell as soons as Whispers of Old is finished.
ElectricDragon said:Imagine a lich using this against a party: 60 years per casting (using my suggestion); how hard is it to create a lair that amplifies the whisperings of the old skeleton-mage so that it can be heard on multiple levels of its complex? Reincarnation is one way back from death by natural causes; is there only this one way?
You can only target on creature at the time with Whispers of Old. Do not ask me for a reasonable in game explaination, because I have none. The only thing I can think of is that what is whispered depends on who the target is. This also ensures that no one that hears the whispering are also affected.
The real explaination is to prevent senarios as the one you mention to occur.
I am actually working on a spell that will be able to bring back people whom have died of natural causes. It will be based on a host body concept.
ElectricDragon said:The unlimited nature of the spell as written is way over the top. Unless you add in some kind of rules for vocal loss due to long usage: "I had to quit the spell because I lost my voice; I was unable to cast spells for over a week afterward."
The vocal loss is not that bad a flavor element. How about: The words whispered are so ancient and hard to pronouce that for each round the spell is active the caster loses his voice for one round afterwards.
Finally I have a question for you, since you seem to be quite experienced when it comes to balancing spells. Should you be able to use Whispers of Old via Scry through the use of Message?
Last edited: