So, this one reminded me of something, like you might see in a chambara flick - the samurai (paladin, whatever), ends up caught between contradictory oaths with no way to salvage his honor (except seppuku, of course, but Paladins don't generally have that option).A question that was left hanging from the other paladin thread. When does a paladin willingly break their oath?
They break the oath under threat to an innocent