Praise and element or aspect of a game or edition you don't like.

[Reynard]

First of all: THIS IS AN EDITION WAR FREE ZONE.

It seems like we have cycled back toward negativity a little bit, so I think we should dispel it by embracing the cool parts of things we generally don't like.

Remember what your momma told you: if you can't say anything nice, don't say anything at all. That, and the Golden Rule should let us have a little fun and maybe even learn something.

For my part: I really, really like 4E's take on diseases. It is elegant and cool and easily adaptable to all sorts of magical and mundane things, from curses and hexes to madness and insanity.

 

[Dannager]

I...I don't have any games or editions I don't like.

 

[amerigoV]

I'm a Savage Worlds guys, so I gots plenty of editions to throw stuff out on:

1e: Love the speed! Plus its what I cut my teeth on. So nostalgia as well.

2e: Love the setting material.

3e: Love the PC building options - even with just the PHB I could build just about anything I wanted. As DM, I pretty much could justify any effect and balance it in the rules.

4e: Love what they did to make the GM's life better. The monster design (roles, mechanics, minions-Solo, etc) and scalability are great.

 

[ShinHakkaider]

My favorite book in the 4E gift set is the Monster Manual. The stat blocks are pretty awesome. I like that only what you need to kick the PC's butts are in the stat block.

It's still an issue for me because I like to customize my monsters and their stat blocks for Pathfinder but the 4E monster stat block design opened my eyes to paring down what I needed for the combat at hand.

 

[(Psi)SeveredHead]

2e: Love Dark Sun. I'm running 4e Dark Sun, but generally I use 2e fluff.

 

[Patryn of Elvenshae]

I...I don't have any games or editions I don't like.

Yeah, this is kinda my problem.

There are games and editions I like less than others, and there are games and editions I wish I could play / could have played more of, but I can't think of any I actively dislike.

 

[MrMyth]

I've been running a Dark Heresy game for some time, and generally dislike all the core aspects of the system - but the setting itself is undeniably awesome, and I love how well they are able to reflect that setting flavor via mechanics in everything from random items to critical deaths to psychic backlashes via Perils of the Warp.

 

[Theo R Cwithin]

Of all frpgs, I've either got no experience with it, or I've enjoyed it. That said, I really, really like the little scotty dog in Monopoly.

 

[Croesus]

OD&D, 1E: Nostalgia, plus no need to convert the old modules

2E: Settings

3E: Improved a number of older rules - BAB, only 3 save categories, AC goes up, multiclassing

4E: NPC, creature, and encounter design rules quick and easy

C&C: Skills

Arduin Grimoire: a gusher of ideas

 

[PapersAndPaychecks]

V:TM has, err... nice T-shirts.