Here is my first attempt at a critical fumble table that takes into account many of the ongoing conditions in 4th edition.
My players wanted to play without my progressive fumbles table so right now we are only using the "Grants Combat Advantage" house rule.
Heroic Progressive Fumble Table (1d20)
Roll Level Condition
Any 1 Grants combat advantage to all attackers
1-10 2 Marked
11-20 2 Grants combat advantage to all attackers
Roll Level Condition
1-5 3 Dazed
6-10 3 Marked
11-20 3 Grants combat advantage to all attackers
1-2 4 Slowed
3-5 4 Dazed
6-10 4 Marked
11-20 4 Grants combat advantage to all attackers
Roll Level Condition
1-2 5 Weakened
3-5 5 Slowed
6-7 5 Dazed
8-10 5 Marked
11-20 5 Grants combat advantage to all attackers
1-2 6 Immobilized
3-4 6 Weakened
5-6 6 Slowed
7-8 6 Dazed
9-10 6 Marked
11-20 6 Grants combat advantage to all attackers
Roll Level Condition
1-2 7 Stunned
3-4 7 Immobilized
4-5 7 Weakened
6-7 7 Slowed
8-9 7 Dazed
10-14 7 Marked
15-20 7 Grants combat advantage to all attackers
1-2 8 Confused
3-4 8 Stunned
5-6 8 Immobilized
7-8 8 Weakened
9-10 8 Slowed
11-12 8 Dazed
13-14 8 Marked
15-20 8 Grants combat advantage to all attackers
Roll Level Condition
1-2 9 Prone
3-4 9 Confused
5-6 9 Stunned
7-8 9 Immobilized
9-10 9 Weakened
11-12 9 Slowed
13-14 9 Dazed
15-16 9 Marked
17-20 9 Grants combat advantage to all attackers
Heroic Level 10 Fumble Table
Roll Level Condition
1-2 10 Helpless
3-4 10 Prone
5-6 10 Confused
7-8 10 Stunned
9-10 10 Immobilized
11-12 10 Weakened
13-14 10 Slowed
15-16 10 Dazed
17-18 10 Marked
19-20 10 Grants combat advantage to all attackers
Paragon Progressive Fumble Table (same as Heroic Level 10 Fumble Table, except add “save ends” to each condition as the levels progress to the Level indicated.
Roll Level Condition
1-2 20+ Helpless; save ends
3-4 19+ Prone; save ends
5-6 18+ Confused; save ends
7-8 17+ Stunned; save ends
9-10 16+ Immobilized; save ends
11-12 15+ Weakened; save ends
13-14 14+ Slowed; save ends
15-16 13+ Dazed; save ends
17-18 12+ Marked; save ends
19-20 11+ Grants combat advantage to all attackers; save ends
My players wanted to play without my progressive fumbles table so right now we are only using the "Grants Combat Advantage" house rule.
Heroic Progressive Fumble Table (1d20)
Roll Level Condition
Any 1 Grants combat advantage to all attackers
1-10 2 Marked
11-20 2 Grants combat advantage to all attackers
Roll Level Condition
1-5 3 Dazed
6-10 3 Marked
11-20 3 Grants combat advantage to all attackers
1-2 4 Slowed
3-5 4 Dazed
6-10 4 Marked
11-20 4 Grants combat advantage to all attackers
Roll Level Condition
1-2 5 Weakened
3-5 5 Slowed
6-7 5 Dazed
8-10 5 Marked
11-20 5 Grants combat advantage to all attackers
1-2 6 Immobilized
3-4 6 Weakened
5-6 6 Slowed
7-8 6 Dazed
9-10 6 Marked
11-20 6 Grants combat advantage to all attackers
Roll Level Condition
1-2 7 Stunned
3-4 7 Immobilized
4-5 7 Weakened
6-7 7 Slowed
8-9 7 Dazed
10-14 7 Marked
15-20 7 Grants combat advantage to all attackers
1-2 8 Confused
3-4 8 Stunned
5-6 8 Immobilized
7-8 8 Weakened
9-10 8 Slowed
11-12 8 Dazed
13-14 8 Marked
15-20 8 Grants combat advantage to all attackers
Roll Level Condition
1-2 9 Prone
3-4 9 Confused
5-6 9 Stunned
7-8 9 Immobilized
9-10 9 Weakened
11-12 9 Slowed
13-14 9 Dazed
15-16 9 Marked
17-20 9 Grants combat advantage to all attackers
Heroic Level 10 Fumble Table
Roll Level Condition
1-2 10 Helpless
3-4 10 Prone
5-6 10 Confused
7-8 10 Stunned
9-10 10 Immobilized
11-12 10 Weakened
13-14 10 Slowed
15-16 10 Dazed
17-18 10 Marked
19-20 10 Grants combat advantage to all attackers
Paragon Progressive Fumble Table (same as Heroic Level 10 Fumble Table, except add “save ends” to each condition as the levels progress to the Level indicated.
Roll Level Condition
1-2 20+ Helpless; save ends
3-4 19+ Prone; save ends
5-6 18+ Confused; save ends
7-8 17+ Stunned; save ends
9-10 16+ Immobilized; save ends
11-12 15+ Weakened; save ends
13-14 14+ Slowed; save ends
15-16 13+ Dazed; save ends
17-18 12+ Marked; save ends
19-20 11+ Grants combat advantage to all attackers; save ends
