Ring of mettle?

[Cecil]

Would it also eliminate the secondary effects of poisons? (For those that are not all-or-nothing?) In my campaign, that might make it fairly valuable. Particularly for someone in the right location.

 

[the Jester]

I'd price it a lil above a ring of evasion, because it affects two categories of saves, but not too much because both are much less likely to gain a benefit from the ring. 40K?

 

[Scion]

Would it also eliminate the secondary effects of poisons? (For those that are not all-or-nothing?) In my campaign, that might make it fairly valuable. Particularly for someone in the right location.

Are there any poisons in the core that are not all or nothing?

 

[Plane Sailing]

and that is it. Reflex saves are easily 4x as common as will and fort combined (for spells that it will work on).

I'm not trying to change your mind (honest!) but I think that another reason why "mettle" would be far, far more valuable is this... the stuff you get reflex saves against is all energy, which can be protected against using resist energy, protection from energy etc. Evasion is a nice additional defence against something which has tons of existing defences.

Fort and Will ST things with a partial effect don't have *any* other countermeasures (with the exception of those few that can be affected by Death Ward).

Those spells were created and balanced (IMO) on the principle that there was no such thing as "evasion" for them to negate the half effect. After all, that's the only reason that horrid wilting is such a high level, surely?

Basically reflex (partial) saves might be much more common, but there are many more defences against them too. The Fort (partial) and Will (partial) spells were designed in a ruleset where there is nothing to remove the partial effect.

"Mettle" was introduced by someone not thinking clearly in a splatbook, who said "hey, why don't I have something like evasion, but for other saving throws?" without thinking it through.

Cheers

 

[The Iron Mark]

Wiat, I thought mettle was for Fort(half) and Will(half) since Evasion is Reflex(half). I'm probably wrong though, since I don't have my books on me at the moment.

Now the Void Incarnate...

 

[Scion]

"Mettle" was introduced by someone not thinking clearly in a splatbook, who said "hey, why don't I have something like evasion, but for other saving throws?" without thinking it through.

This sounds like you are assuming it is too strong and should not have been made But as you said the same earlier effectively it wasnt hard to guess.

Effectively this ring would partially protect the wearer from 15 spells about.

There are other spells which protect against some/most of them even. But then I have known people who ban evasion because they feel it is too strong and not thought out.

Basically reflex (partial) saves might be much more common, but there are many more defences against them too. The Fort (partial) and Will (partial) spells were designed in a ruleset where there is nothing to remove the partial effect.

This is true, but several of those ways would protect against spells I listed before as well (such as the shouts for example).

It is very interesting to see where the balance really resides though.

On one had you have an ability to fully resist nearly every damaging spell/power in the game.

On the other hand you have the ability to ignore a handful of spells whose secondary effects happen to fall into a certain category.

The first can be overcome through other means (resistance, immunity, etc)

The second has similar things (spell turning, high tough ac, blanket immunity, etc)

The first seems to be benign enough that there is an improved version.

The second has no such parallel, but then it would be nearly impossible to draw one, because those things that it works on generally have a massive primary effect and then a secondary tagged on almost as an afterthought. Most of the secondary effects are fairly minor, there are about 2 exceptions.


I am still undecided it is a rough call really. I dont want to price it too high because I want it to actually be able to be used, and since its uses are limited (and they are limited, very) then it is more difficult to actually be shown to be useful. Cant price it too low though, otherwise everyone would have one.. but then, even if everyone did have one being able to save for none on about 15 spells or so seems pretty minor.. very tough call.

 

[Plane Sailing]

Wiat, I thought mettle was for Fort(half) and Will(half) since Evasion is Reflex(half). I'm probably wrong though, since I don't have my books on me at the moment. - although maybe I'm misunderstanding your point

Reflex is normally Reflex(half) anyway! Evasion gives Reflex(none), and improved evasion means that you take half damage even if you fail your save.

Scion - you detected my carefully concealed bias against the ability!

 

[Scion]

Reflex is normally Reflex(half) anyway!

And fort/will are usually (negates)

Scion - you detected my carefully concealed bias against the ability!

I am just that good