• NOW LIVE! Into the Woods--new character species, eerie monsters, and haunting villains to populate the woodlands of your D&D games.

RotK reviews starting to roll in

Saw it last night.

They had a special screening in Toronto last night, as part of Alliance Atlantis' 2003 holiday thanks. (They distribute New Line pictures up here).

The print arrived about a half-hour after the event was scheduled to start, and then they needed an additional 40 minutes to rewind it, but after waiting a year, what's another hour or two.

Now, I'm a sucker for those ultimate bravery scenes, like the one in Fellowship where all present are arguing at the council of Elrond, and then Frodo stands up and does his, "I will take the ring. Though I do not know the way..."

I'm probably getting soft, thanks to all the little girls in my house, but those type of moments just get me all choked up. So, I loved Fellowship for that scene and the "Buckleberry Ferry" scene, where Merry and Pippin selflessly help Frodo get out of the Shire with no questions asked. Of course, that's what the Fellowship is all about, right?

And I loved Two Towers, especially the Extended Edition, though it didn't have any *gulp*ing moments for me (the Gollum scene comes closest, 'cause you just feel for the little bugger!)

As should be obvious from the subject of the movie, Return of the King has about a million of those "ultimate bravery" moments. You know, all the stuff where one dude says, "We cannot defeat Sauron's army. There are too many of them!" and then one of the main characters does his moment where he responds, "No, we cannot defeat them. But we will fight, and meet such a glorious end!" and then I get all misty.

There's one bit that wasn't as dramatic as I'd have liked (maybe 'cause I knew what was coming), and I would have liked a scene or two of Aragorn struggling with his decisions, but I think the movie overall packs an unbelievable emotional punch. If I didn't have to maintain my cool 'cause I work with a bunch of people who like to brag about how they've fallen asleep in both movies and think the hobbits are "really gay", then I may actually have shed a tear or two at some of the speeches. Looking forward to seeing it again with my wife, who will mock me for tearing up, but only for a moment. ;)

After the movie, it's odd, but I got really melancholy. It's like breaking up with a girlfriend -- you're happy the relationships finally over (for whatever reason), but the moment she's gone, you find yourself thinking about how lonely next Christmas will be. (OK, that's not a perfect analogy by any stretch, but I'm not feeling so well today).

It's sad to say goodbye to these movies, 'cause they've just become such a focus over the past three years, and you know that you'll never see a new Lord of the Rings movie again.

Of course, the Extended Edition will likely come out in the summer next year, so at least you'll get a brief refresher (it's like a booty call!).

Anyway, that's my non-spoiler review. A great emotional piece that caps off the trilogy nicely. Epic battles and rousing words. Sacrifice and nobility. Good stuff.

- James
 

log in or register to remove this ad

Hypersmurf said:
I've got my ticket to a Cast and Crew showing on the 16th... but just like the last two years, I can't be bothered taking a day or two off work, travelling down to Wellington, etc, etc, just to see it 36 hours early.

So, just like the last two years, I'll see it with my gaming group at midnight on the 18th...

-Hyp.

I was at the first cast and crew screening, and given I was living in Wellington it was no hassle at all to go. And I have to say that it was a wierd experience. The crew (which was really who the audience was) would cheer at the wierdest things, mostly because they were incredibly difficult effects that looked to the untrained observer like me to be completely normal. It was only afterwards that my friend who took me explained what was going on that I stopped being confused.
 

FJ -- I'm totally with you, man. Although in addition to the "ultimate bravery" moments, I get pretty moved by the "family" moments -- in Two Towers when that Eorling woman sets her two kids on a horse and tells them to run; or the battle scenes intercut with women and children sitting under the castle in the caves, hugging each other uncertainly -- or when the boys and old men are taken away from their families and armed to man the wall at the Hornburg. I'd say Two Towers definately has it's emotionally moving moments.

By the way, the extended editions typically don't come out until November; I'm looking forward to next Christmas break when I can have the Lord of the Rings marathon at my house, hopefully on a new, big TV with 6.0 digital audio by then as well. ;)
 

Fiery James said:
Of course, the Extended Edition will likely come out in the summer next year, so at least you'll get a brief refresher (it's like a booty call!).

The current rumor is that the TC of RotK will be out on DVD end of May next year. The extended edtion will still be November. But they ate putting out the TC earlier, New Line does not have another movie to pimp, so that will hold us over until the EE.
 

Joshua Dyal said:
FJ -- I'm totally with you, man. Although in addition to the "ultimate bravery" moments, I get pretty moved by the "family" moments -- in Two Towers when that Eorling woman sets her two kids on a horse and tells them to run; or the battle scenes intercut with women and children sitting under the castle in the caves, hugging each other uncertainly -- or when the boys and old men are taken away from their families and armed to man the wall at the Hornburg. I'd say Two Towers definately has it's emotionally moving moments.

By the way, the extended editions typically don't come out until November; I'm looking forward to next Christmas break when I can have the Lord of the Rings marathon at my house, hopefully on a new, big TV with 6.0 digital audio by then as well. ;)


You know what, you're right about that stuff in Two Towers. I do get choked up when the two kids are on the horse -- and when they're finally reunited with their mother at Helm's Deep.

Rumor has it that the DVDs will be bumped up next year. We'll likely see the regular version in May, followed by the Extended Edition in August. They haven't given an exact reason, but further rumors suggest that either they don't want the EE going up against the Star Wars Trilogy DVD set, or just the opposite -- they want to release a total trilogy to take on Star Wars.

Nothing's confirmed, but I'd keep my ear open for an earlier release next year.

- JB
 

Fiery James said:
<SNIP>

After the movie, it's odd, but I got really melancholy. It's like breaking up with a girlfriend -- you're happy the relationships finally over (for whatever reason), but the moment she's gone, you find yourself thinking about how lonely next Christmas will be. (OK, that's not a perfect analogy by any stretch, but I'm not feeling so well today).

It's sad to say goodbye to these movies, 'cause they've just become such a focus over the past three years, and you know that you'll never see a new Lord of the Rings movie again.

Of course, the Extended Edition will likely come out in the summer next year, so at least you'll get a brief refresher (it's like a booty call!).

Anyway, that's my non-spoiler review. A great emotional piece that caps off the trilogy nicely. Epic battles and rousing words. Sacrifice and nobility. Good stuff.

- James

I saw the TV Guide with the LOTR covers the other day, and the caption is "The End of the Saga." And I too got sad. It's been with us for years, speculating about what's in, what's out, critiquing, reviewing, anticipating, and all that's about to end.

I can't imagine another set of films generating as much sustained interest and passion, and least for me and my circle. It really is the end of an era.

PS
 

If there are any questions, my wife (Tory Adore) could try to answer some (from a non-purists POV).
She got to see the movie at a preview (I had a family commitment) :mad:

She said it a VERY satisfying conclusion to the epic fantasy, and better than TTT.
 

Watching the Council scene in Fellowship my daughter whispered to me about Boromir, "I don't trust him." and when he did try to take the Ring, "See!" followed so few minutes later by tears in her eyes. The death of Boromir is great acting in as perfectly realized a scene as could have been done.

In the Two Towers, Haldir leading the elves to Helm's Deep was way cool and their death in the battle was poignant.

We're so looking forward to this movie.
 
Last edited:

Fiery James said:
Rumor has it that the DVDs will be bumped up next year. We'll likely see the regular version in May, followed by the Extended Edition in August. They haven't given an exact reason, but further rumors suggest that either they don't want the EE going up against the Star Wars Trilogy DVD set, or just the opposite -- they want to release a total trilogy to take on Star Wars.

Couldn't it just simply be because PJ and company don't have a movie to finish producing at the same time as they work on putting two separate DVD sets together?
 

Welverin said:
Couldn't it just simply be because PJ and company don't have a movie to finish producing at the same time as they work on putting two separate DVD sets together?

I think its because New Line does not have another LotR movie to pimp. PJ and company are starting work on King Kong, while working on RotK DVD. I heard the TC DVD will be out in May and the EE November still.
 

Into the Woods

Remove ads

Top