The situation:
Party is fighting an adult Shadow Dragon in a cave. The dragon has cast Deeper Darkness on itself, so when my PC goes to the mouth of the cave, she can't see squat. So she casts Limited Wish to replicate True Seeing, then casts Project Image into the cave, where she can see two other party members in melee with the dragon.
Next round, cast Bigby's Clenched Fist on the dragon.
The problem:
The Shadow Dragon has Blur and Mirror Image cast upon itself. Since I have True Seeing up, I can penetrate both illusions. However, the question is, can Bigby's fist ignore these illusions too?
My DM's ruling:
Since Bigby's hand uses its own attack roll (e.g. not based on your own strength or BAB), it cannot penentrate these illusions, even if you can. Therefore it suffers 20% miss per Blur and may hit a Mirror Image anyway.
My stance:
Under Bigby's fist it says that the hand's ability to detect invisible creatures is no better than yours. Seems clear to me, but my DM disagreed.
My request to you:
Any additional evidence/rules quotes you could provide? Sage advice?
Thanks!
Party is fighting an adult Shadow Dragon in a cave. The dragon has cast Deeper Darkness on itself, so when my PC goes to the mouth of the cave, she can't see squat. So she casts Limited Wish to replicate True Seeing, then casts Project Image into the cave, where she can see two other party members in melee with the dragon.
Next round, cast Bigby's Clenched Fist on the dragon.
The problem:
The Shadow Dragon has Blur and Mirror Image cast upon itself. Since I have True Seeing up, I can penetrate both illusions. However, the question is, can Bigby's fist ignore these illusions too?
My DM's ruling:
Since Bigby's hand uses its own attack roll (e.g. not based on your own strength or BAB), it cannot penentrate these illusions, even if you can. Therefore it suffers 20% miss per Blur and may hit a Mirror Image anyway.
My stance:
Under Bigby's fist it says that the hand's ability to detect invisible creatures is no better than yours. Seems clear to me, but my DM disagreed.
My request to you:
Any additional evidence/rules quotes you could provide? Sage advice?
Thanks!