Sure sounded like you were before now. But if you are now saying you don't judge it as good or bad I won't argue.Ahh I see the sticking point but it doesn’t need to be one. I don’t believe that using player only knowledge is good or bad. I make no value judgement on the right way to play or not.
Let's suppose this is true. It still doesn't mean that players who don't use out of character knowledge are immature.I just think that not using your own knowledge requires restraint which itself requires a certain amount of maturity.