G
Guest 6801328
Guest
I hope someday you play a good call off Cthulhu game with a good keeper. I had that feeling recently and I been playing for decades.
We're like junkies trying to replicate that original high, huh?
I hope someday you play a good call off Cthulhu game with a good keeper. I had that feeling recently and I been playing for decades.
What in what I said gave you the impression that I would police someone else's characters?That’s great! If you think it’s fun to pretend to not know things, go for it.
The problems start when you start also role-playing other people’s characters, by telling them what their characters know.
(By the way, I also want to point out that in another thread I said that arguing this question is the true Essence of D&D.)
We're like junkies trying to replicate that original high, huh?
What in what I said gave you the impression that I would police someone else's characters?
has the language/tone of a sentiment commonly expressed by people who think there's only one kind of roleplaying, and it involves pretending to not know stuff. Those people, even if they aren't directly telling other people how to play, are definitely "policing" roleplaying.I don't consider it avoiding meta game info, I consider it role playing my character.
Agreed. Certainly pretending not to know doesn't do it. That's like pretending to not know whodunnit in a mystery novel so you can re-read it and still be surprised.Yup. And I find that the less I know of the setting, monsters, and the spells the better.