Ovinomancer
No flips for you!
How do I do this, though? Do I make a bad choice, knowing it's a bad choice, just because it'll show I'm trying really hard to not know it's a bad choice?I'm in the camp of, "Yes, but that information may not be correct or complete." Fire stops trolls from regenerating is pretty vague. Does it mean a troll won't regenerate any fire damage? Does it mean you have to completely immolate the troll to keep it from coming back?
When dealing with veteran players I find it most fun for everyone to treat their hard earned meta knowledge as the kind of rumors and stories their characters know from being immersed in the culture.