Sundering a Shield? Opposed Attack Roll?

[Hypersmurf]

Not in the original question. And he also pointed out that there could be a problem with his Mercurial sword, but he would just use a normal magical Greatsword he already had instead.

Yup, and since he has MWP with longsword, he could use the Greatsword as a Large longsword with no problem.

I do not think so. A medium Greatsword is a Greatsword made especially for a Small character. And is basically a longsword.

Yes. What makes you think, then, that anything I typed was confused? That was exactly my point...

-Hyp.

 

[AGGEMAM]

Yes. What makes you think, then, that anything I typed was confused? That was exactly my point...

Well, read the rest of the paragraph.

 

[Shadowlore]

Yup, and since he has MWP with longsword, he could use the Greatsword as a Large longsword with no problem.

-Hyp.

Only problem with that is that a Mercurial longsword and a Mercurial greatsword require *different* EWP.

So, in the case of my Mercurial GS, if it feels and acts like a Mercurial Longsword due to size change in me, and not it, then it should be treated as a Large Mercurial Longwsord. Hence, I would need an EWP:Mercurial Longsword.

That's how I'd rule it anyway. I'll probably wind up having my MGS enhanced, or try to find/comission a new magical one. But not while in these mines ...

ahh what tangled webs unfold
when ascension is the goal.

 

[Hypersmurf]

Well, read the rest of the paragraph.

So?

Everything I've discussed has been Small-Medium or Medium-Large crossovers, which fall within the "one size category" limit you mentioned.

-Hyp.

 

[AGGEMAM]

Only problem with that is that a Mercurial longsword and a Mercurial greatsword require *different* EWP.

I do think that in this particular case, Hypersmurf, did not mean Mercurial weapons.

So, in the case of my Mercurial GS, if it feels and acts like a Mercurial Longsword due to size change in me, and not it, then it should be treated as a Large Mercurial Longwsord. Hence, I would need an EWP:Mercurial Longsword.

Actually EWP(Large Mercurial Longsword), but since EWP would apply any size of the same to weapon, that is ok. As long as your size is the appropiate one, that is.

 

[AGGEMAM]

Everything I've discussed has been Small-Medium or Medium-Large crossovers, which fall within the "one size category" limit you mentioned.

Correct me if I have misunderstood you, but I thought you wrote that a Large character could use a Medium Greatsword, that is two size categories removed, is it not ?

 

[Hypersmurf]

Correct me if I have misunderstood you, but I thought you wrote that a Large character could use a Medium Greatsword, that is two size categories removed, is it not ?

It is two categories removed.

But I've just read through all my message four times, and I cannot find anywhere where I've got a Large creature with a Medium Greatsword.

Feel free to quote me if you can find it...

-Hyp.

 

[AGGEMAM]

But I've just read through all my message four times, and I cannot find anywhere where I've got a Large creature with a Medium Greatsword.

Ditto.

I stand corrected.

 

[Hypersmurf]

I stand corrected.

Gah Where's the point of arguing if you're going to be all gracious about it?

-Hyp.

 

[melkoriii]

That is why the DMG suggests that you let magical armors and shields resize to fit the wearer.

So does that mean I can have made a tiny sized Mitheral Full Plate at half the costs to make then have it enchanted to +1 so I can wear it?

heheh Just know that will go over like a Pregnant Pollvilter.