The Three Hobbit Films

No thank you. I could do without the soft-core porn version of The Silmarillion, thankyouverymuch!


Oh, I think they could keep it tame enough for a PG-13 audience, if they so chose, and the potential to draw a younger audience after a successful Hobbit (and previously LotR) would be a big enough incentive to for them to stay that course, I believe.
 

log in or register to remove this ad

Possibly they could end the first one in Mirkwood around the time the dwarves get caught by the spiders. Anywhere around there would make a good cliffhanger too. Though the entry to Mirkwood sounds like a good spot too.

I'm not exactly sure how much this is going to be stretched out. There is a wealth of background material in the Appendices. Perhaps they'll go into detail with Thror's ill-fated expedition to Moria and the war between the dwarves and the orcs, and perhaps give us some detail on Thrain's imprisonment. We might see some bits of the White Council debating on whetheror not to act against Sauron as the Necromancer in Dol Guldur. And there is the things that happen between the Hobbit and the Lord of the Rings that could be covered.

Also, some of the dwarves will probably get more time spent on them than was spent on them in the book. Only Thorin, Balin, Fili, Kili, and Bombur (and possibly Gloin) get much of any attention in the book, and here the dwarves will probably need to presented as more than just extras. That will probably stretch things out.
 

Regardless of how long the movies are and what's in them, I expect all three to be good fantasy movies--and that's a rarity. For that reason I hope that they do extremely well.
 

Not to0 thrilled about the Hobbit being 3 movies.
First I share the fear the the movies will be stretched as the Hobbit is a small(er) book and because Jackson sits on some interesting IPs which now get delayed even more (if he makes something out of them at all).
 
Last edited:

Three seems like a stretch, but if the trailer is any indication, I think this will be a fine fantasy series.

God knows we need them, because D&D can't deliver in that department. :eek:
 

Remove ads

Top