Tinkering with Eberron...

If there was ONE thing I would change about Eberron it would be the Alignment System. I'd drop it entirely if not for the rules that I would have to alter. Alignment really seems like it was kinda shoehorned into Eberron anyways. Dropping the alignment system would, IMO, contribute to the noir feel of the setting. But, I'm lazy, and I don't feel like rewriting the Paladin and other things that rely on Alignment...
 

log in or register to remove this ad

Thanks for the comments. I do agree with Derbacher's suggestion on increasing the amount of Psionics in the world of Eberron.. Especially with multiple psionic-focused races (The Illithid, the Inspired, the Kalashtar, etc) being around to spread the "wealth"...

There is, however, another point about Eberron that bothers me that I can't help but want to change: The Drow.

I'm sorry, but reading all of the descriptions of Eberron's Drow, including the write-up in Races of Eberron, and I can't help but think: "These aren't Drow.. They're dark-skinned Wild Elves." It's not just a matter of spider-worshipping, either. These guys just aren't worthy of the name Drow, 'cause they're not Dark Elves.

To me, Dark Elves are intended to be darker mirror images of the Elves: where normal Elves are peace-loving, Dark Elves are war-mongering; where normal Elves are honorable and seek to work well with others, Dark Elves are decietful and seek to manipulate or dominate others; Where normal Elves say Up, Dark Elves say Down, and so on.. So, when I see the Dark Elves living as semi-primitive nomads in Xen'drik while their pale-skinned cousins have thriving civilisations in Aerenal, Valenar and amongst the people of Khorvaire, I just find that to be an affront to my Inner Drow.

So, here's my simple fix for the Drow of Eberron: those nomadic tribes of Drow? They're just clans of professional hunters, scouts and treasure hunters, who also serve as a "buffer" for the rest of Drow Civilisation, which is far more sophisticated then most outsiders realize. While not entirely Evil per say, the Drow Empire of Os'Jhal is a very harsh and pragmatic realm, almost darwinian in it's people's constant search to gain power and dominance.

Every Drow is raised on the stories of how their ancestors were once enslaved and abused by the Giants. Upon winning their freedom when their masters lost their power, the Drow swore they would never be anyone's thralls ever again. They have vowed to become mightier then the giants, mightier then the dragons, even.. And to achieve this might, the Drow will stop at nothing: they will retrieve the lost magical lore of their fallen masters; they will weed weaknesses such as fear and mercy out of every successive generation of Drow; they will breed new slaves and living weapons, if need be..

For a good inspiration on what I'm going for, picture Andromeda's Nitzcheans, or S.M. Stirling's Dominion of the Draka: these Drow are racial supremacists, social darwinists, facists and slavers... In short, real Drow. :]

I can live with Drow not being linked to Spiders, or not living in the Underdark. Heck, I even find it refreshing. But in my honest opinion, if the Drow aren't at least somewhat evil as a culture, then they're not real Drow.
 

Sorry, but I have to disagree. I'm so happy to see no "real Drow" in Eberron. I was sick of them in Greyhawk, doubly sick of them in FR; this is one race that I just cannot ever miss. :p
 

derbacher said:
Sorry, but I have to disagree. I'm so happy to see no "real Drow" in Eberron. I was sick of them in Greyhawk, doubly sick of them in FR; this is one race that I just cannot ever miss. :p

Then cut them out of Eberron entirely.. Better no Drow then watered-down Drow wannabes..
 


Captain Tagon said:
Or possibly better a fresh new look on an old and tired race instead of the angsty cliche?

You can put a fresh new look on an old and tired race without taking away what defined it's essence.. Just look at Eberron's Elves, Dwarves, Gnomes, Half-elves, Halflings, Orcs and Half-Orcs... They all have fresh, new twists, but they still have elements which remind the reader of the older versions (Dwarven Greed, Elven Aloofness, Gnomish Curiosity, etc)...

But apparantly, you can't put a new, fresh spin on the Drow without throwing away everything that was nifty about them and making them into jungle hunters who aren't even that evil, just territorial. ...No, I'm sorry, but like I said: Those aren't Dark Elves, those are Wild Elves painted black. And if I want Wild Elves, I'll use Wild Elves. When I look for Dark Elves, I better get the damn Dark Elves, or else I'm gonna get annoyed.

Furthermore, you can reinvent the Dark Elves quite easily without losing the basic concept of the race, which is "These are Elves, only Dark and Twisted." The basic concept I mentionned has none of the tired old cliches: Matriarchy, Spider-Worship, Underdark, etc, yet I still have the Drow as Dark, Sinister and Ruthless Imperialists.. Just with a new twist..
 



LoneWolf23 said:
To me, Dark Elves are intended to be darker mirror images of the Elves: where normal Elves are peace-loving, Dark Elves are war-mongering; where normal Elves are honorable and seek to work well with others, Dark Elves are decietful and seek to manipulate or dominate others; Where normal Elves say Up, Dark Elves say Down, and so on..

I think that that is the point, actually. Eberron's inherent tendency is to ambiguate black-and-white relationships; it is thus natural to divorce the Drow from the Elves in terms of being "mirror images" of each other.
 

I put all the devils on Risia and all the demons on Fernia and tinkered with elemental resistances to fit. Instead of the odd divisions where Shavarath natives are sundered(in both space and ethos) from their kin, the beings on Shavarrath are originally from Risia, Fernia or Syrania. Shavarath serves simply as a battlefield.
 

Remove ads

Top