Vader vs Soth: Fight! Who wins?

Jfdlsjfd · Dec 22, 2021

Sosh: "You can't win, Vader. I am cursed to live forever."
Vader making a slicing gesture with his lightsaber, mildly annoyed: "which half of you is cursed exactly? Your upper torso?"
Sosh: "That's just a flesh wound!"

aco175 · Dec 22, 2021

I could not find a Vader doing this, but he could.

Paul Farquhar · Dec 22, 2021

Morrus said:
No reinforcements allowed. On foot.

Who wins and why?

Batman.

Batman always wins.

Davies · Dec 22, 2021

Soth summons his legions to wear Vader down, then takes him out with various magics. Vader puts up a fight and leaves Soth crippled, but Soth is still moving in the aftermath.

Dioltach · Dec 22, 2021

Does Soth have a spell to conjure sand? Because we know how Vader feels about sand ....

Dausuul · Dec 22, 2021

Davies said:
Soth summons his legions to wear Vader down, then takes him out with various magics. Vader puts up a fight and leaves Soth crippled, but Soth is still moving in the aftermath.

It was specified there are no reinforcements. If they're allowed to bring allies, Vader wins easily; he has the resources of a galactic empire to draw on while Soth has one measly castle. Granted, each one of Soth's skeleton warriors can probably account for dozens of stormtroopers, but sheer weight of numbers still wins in the end.

Anyway, Soth's twisted sense of honor wouldn't let him cheat in a duel. Vader probably wouldn't, either.

Jfdlsjfd · Dec 22, 2021

It's said they start on foot. Not where they are.

Soth starts on foot in his castle. Vader starts on foot landing on the other side of the planet, then proceed to force choke Soth. Given the evidence that he can Force choke Admiral Ozzel from on ISD to another, there is a strong chance Vader has abilities that far exceed in range what Soth can do, even PWK.