Celebrim
Legend
I disagree with this....*proceeds to not disagree with this*...If this kind of thing needs to be attached to the fighter class, then I think those class abilities need to be based on Intelligence and Charisma [just like you said]....
Errr.... ok. Yes, a high level fighter that didn't invest anything in tactics and command and which had low intelligence or charisma is probably not someone you want leading your army. Yes, a scholar of tactics and command could probably do better, although even said dumb but personally puissant fighter could probably command an army slightly better than someone that had no experience or knowledge of war at all and has never taken or received orders.