What sort of product do you want to buy that no one is producing?

[eyebeams]

Mechancis wise I would love to see a book that had ways to modify the core classes. We don't need all these new prestige classes and base classes. All we need is a book that has ways to modify the existing classes. We get a little of it here and there but no one seems to want to devote a book to it. Everyone wants to reinvent the wheel.

<plug>
The second product link in my (Steel and Stealth) sig is *exactly* that. It takes four classes (Fighter, Monk, Ranger, Rogue) and strips them down into the kinds of options found in books like Unearthed Arcana, but much more extensive. I'm planning on expanding this product line in the future. It started because I'm playing a Monk/Rogue right now and wanted ways to tweak each to fit my character's concept, but I like the class system and didn't want to do the point-buy thing.
</plug>

 

[Ry]

An extremely rules-light system with an extremely highly detailed world.

 

[Shadowslayer]

I'd settle for something like the Fantastic Locations maps, but aimed squarely at RPG players, with more generic scenes: A campsite, a hill, a small bridge across a creek, inside a small cave etc.. You could fit 2 on each side of a poster...they don't all have to be poster sized battle maps.

I liked the idea someone had of the monster cards. I already make my own, but it'd be nice to just be able to buy em ready to go. I'd even go one better and wish for a similar thing, but with NPCs. Sort of a Roques Gallery in card form.

Also, while I'm dreaming, how about a line of minis based on more "classical" styled artwork. (There's still quite a few of us that still LIKE pointy hatted wizards and realistically scaled weapons).

ALso, put me on record as one of the ones who likes the new MM format. Throw things if you want, but I'd like to see more of that. I think a Monster Book should have more than pics and statblocks, and the last one was pretty good IMO (format wise anyway...some of the critters themselves seemed sorta goofy to me.)

 

[Kafkonia]

- A Fantasy version of the d20 Menace Manual giving low/medium/high level Ordinaries and Heros in a fantasy setting. Everyone Else comes close, but I want fantasy Guards, Criminals, Spies, etc - folks who'd make good protagonists in a human-centric campaign.

I've been toying with this idea. Would you buy it without artwork?

 

[Kafkonia]

People who don't use the non-core material will be ticked off because there's support for materials they don't use (why is all this space being wasted on some stupid wu-jen class I've never heard of? Waaaah!)

The PHBII included an alternate ability for this class I'd never heard of, the Marshall. Not only didn't I complain, but I wound up buying the Miniatures Handbook expressly to get the class!

 

[Whizbang Dustyboots]

Also, while I'm dreaming, how about a line of minis based on more "classical" styled artwork. (There's still quite a few of us that still LIKE pointy hatted wizards and realistically scaled weapons).

Goodman Games is making miniatures for you, then. They even have one called Pointy Hatted Wizard.

 

[Kafkonia]

... what about the lollipop in the shape of Tiamat? Flavored like Tiamat?

What flavour is that, anyway? Neapolitan?

Beware the Neapolitan Dragon!

 

[Thanee]

A book without blatantly obvious errors or other issues would be nice, every once in a while.

Bye
Thanee

 

[Thanee]

An extremely rules-light system with an extremely highly detailed world.

Talislanta

Bye
Thanee

 

[mattcolville]

Rules on running a domain that blend with rules for war/mass battles. This is more a request for WotC to give it a shot, I know 3rd parties have it done in spades.

I think WotC believes this is not an appropriate product for D&D, being beyond the scope of the core play.

Which makes me happy. I'm working on such a product as we speak.