Which version of D&D for young children?

If you expect her to actually read the rulebook and learn the game more-or-less on her own, then the 1983 red-box D&D Basic Set (edited by Frank Mentzer, with cover art by Larry Elmore) is by far the best choice. It's at a reading and content level suitable to 9-10 year olds (but not totally insulting to older readers like the later Black Box reputedly was), and after reading through the first book (and playing the choose-your-own-adventure style intro adventures) even a total newbie with no previous knowledge or experience whatsoever should have a very good grasp of both the principles and the rules of the game. By reading through the second book that same newbie should be able to DM the game as well.

If, however, she's going to be playing under the guidance and tutelage of more experienced players (i.e. you) then any of OD&D (1974), Holmes Basic (1977-78), Moldvay Basic (1981), Mentzer Basic (1983), or the Black Box (1991) should all work equally well -- the rules are mostly the same between them, and much simpler than either edition of AD&D or d20 (not as many numbers, modifiers, special cases, etc.).
 

log in or register to remove this ad


If you can find an old copy of the Dungeon! boardgame, it's an excellent intro to some of the basic concepts of D&D and the general theme of dungeon exploration and monster bashing. They're still fairly commonly available on ebay and pretty age-appropriate for your daughter. (My 4 year old loves it!!!)

Once she's 8 or 9, any of the old Basic sets would do the trick. The 1983 Mentzer version probably combines the best rules with the most accessable presentation. I grew up with the 1981 rules and prefer those from a content standpoint. But as a intro to playing, the 1983 rules are probably a little better for kids.
 

rogueattorney said:
If you can find an old copy of the Dungeon! boardgame, it's an excellent intro to some of the basic concepts of D&D and the general theme of dungeon exploration and monster bashing. They're still fairly commonly available on ebay and pretty age-appropriate for your daughter. (My 4 year old loves it!!!)
Excellent suggestion! I completely forgot about Dungeon! I remember when it came out but for whatever reason I never bought it (probably too busy playing OD&D).
 

Other boardgames to check out are HeroQuest and Dragon Strike.

But if you are set on D&D, I'd recommend the 1991 Black Box set. It takes PCs up to level five with the Mentzer rules, after which you are expected to continue with the Rules Cyclopedia. It also comes with a board/map and a whole bunch of fold-up pieces for characters.
 





I don't agree at all on going backward several versions of the game to teach it. It will just make it harder when you want to upgrade. Plus, you have to find it somewhere.

If you want to start now, start with the Basic Game boxed set. I have two young boys, and we started there (and D&D minis, lots of minis). There are plenty of ways to keep things really, really simple. Frankly, I'd wait and see what intro products are coming for 4E, I'm betting they have some entry products.
 

Remove ads

Top