Why Are There No Reviews of 4th Edition Material?

[Crothian]

Reviews are being worked on, they just don't write themself. Today should see the Adventure's Vault review posted with the FRPG following in a few days (I hope).

As always we encourage people to review what they have read and or used. The review sections works best when many people are reviewing books even if all you do is review one, it is very helpful.

 

[JoeGKushner]

http://www.enworld.org/forum/pdf-reviews/242745-forgoten-heroes-fang-fist-song.html

Review of the Forgotten Heroes 4e/GSL (no OGL work around here).

 

[Filcher]

Wizards product reviews:
Keep on the Shadowfell

3rd party 4e reviews:
Dragora's Dungeon
Dragora's Dungeon (#2)
Dragora's Dungeon (another one!)
Sellswords of Punjar
Campaign Record
Sellswords of Punjar (#2)

Cheers!

*blink* Wow. I did one review hadn't realized that the 3pp efforts were getting all the press. Props to the other reviewers (looking at you Joe) for the valuable service.

 

[Filcher]

Additional 4E reviews, still Goodman Games material

Character Codex:
http://www.enworld.org/forum/rpg-book-reviews/242370-character-codex.html

DM Campaign Record:
http://www.enworld.org/forum/rpg-book-reviews/240316-dm-campaign-record.html

 

[Morrus]

I really need to work out how to set up some kind a system whereby people get rewarded in some way for posting reviews.

 

[Deuce Traveler]

I really need to work out how to set up some kind a system whereby people get rewarded in some way for posting reviews.

Like baking us cookies?

 

[JoeGKushner]

Like baking us cookies?

You get one xp for this valuable idea.

Hell, it could be a brand!

"Cookied by Morrus. Don't just eat, kick ass!"

 

[Wolv0rine]

They could have little prizes baked inside them. I can see the ad line now... "eat the cookie, take it's stuff"

 

[John Cooper]

As for why I, as a staff reviewer, don't have any reviews of the 4E material, it's rather simple: the 4E game doesn't seem like anything I'd enjoy, and thus it's not anything I'd choose to spend my own money on. Likewise, for its part, Wizards of the Coast has apparently decided to stop sending me material to review.

So, it looks like I'll be the slightly-out-of-touch staff reviewer who continues to review 3.5 products (fortunately, I've got a lot of 3.5 WotC books that I've purchased myself that will keep me busy for awhile).

 

[Crothian]

So, it looks like I'll be the slightly-out-of-touch staff reviewer who continues to review 3.5 products (fortunately, I've got a lot of 3.5 WotC books that I've purchased myself that will keep me busy for awhile).

Nothing wrong with that. 3e is a great game and I am still reviewing many of modules that I have ran and will be running.