Originally posted by Henry Ristamar, I have to go 180 degrees in the other direction, with respect to Storm & Magneto. I think Ian McKellan was PERFECT as Magneto - I can't think of a better choice in Hollywood to play him.
He wasn't a
bad choice... he simply may not have been the
best choice. But as I said, a lot of the blame falls on the writing and direction (cheesy villainous scheme, ugly costume design). He just wasn't as threatening and domineering and as powerful as he could have been, which isn't really McKellen's fault. He did good with what was there.
Also, I know they were trying to be a bit more 'realistic' in the movie, as well, which is why Eric was portrayed by someone as aged as McKellen. I don't particularly agree with that decision (which is why, IMO, he may not have been the very best choice), but that's just me. My main complaints reside in the paragraph above, though.
Halle Berry as storm could have definitely been better, but her look was a PERFECT tribute to the 1970's and early 80's storm, in my opinion. THe long hair. The perfect skin and affected beauty was spot on - her performance, however, was very unconfident, because she obviously was not at all familiar with the character. But then, you would have had to have read a LOT of comic books to get that.
Yes, her performance was severely lacking, IMO. I could have overlooked the terrible wig (which looks better in the X2 trailer, BTW) had she not been so 'un-Storm-like'. I think anyone who read a few comics and/or watched the cartoon could easily take notice. And I don't know why they'd want to give tribute to the 70's and 80's Storm, as they didn't feel the need to have anyone else look retro (save for Magneto's costume.... ugh). I certainly hope Beast doesn't show up as his non-blue-'n'-fuzzy persona.