Grog pretty much went down the list and hit every nail squarely on the head, so I'd be interested to know what makes you think he completely missed the character.You completely missed the character then. All I got was that he's the anti of what I've seen on other shows.
He's the "anti" of what you've seen on other shows? What did he say or do that was so different? What, nobody's ever done a rule-breaking cop on the edge before?