Sure, I acknowledge I don't know Planescape, because at the time it was on the shelves, my homebrew campaign was already extraplanar (so I wasn't interested as a DM) and there was a remote possibility that I could play a PC in a Planescape campaign, so I didn't get it in order not to spoil the fun.
But I refuse the 2ers the right to impose their fluff on Next, just because Planescape=2e=paramount of planar goodness. The fluff change from 1e to 2e was real and tiresome for me, so I can sympathize with those who were pissed off by 4e take on so many setting issues (even of I generally consider 4e versions to be vastly more interesting than prior versions).
If you chose to be inclusive and retro-compatible, you can't seriously consider 2e as a starting point, as it excludes everything prior 2e from your inclusiveness )
But I refuse the 2ers the right to impose their fluff on Next, just because Planescape=2e=paramount of planar goodness. The fluff change from 1e to 2e was real and tiresome for me, so I can sympathize with those who were pissed off by 4e take on so many setting issues (even of I generally consider 4e versions to be vastly more interesting than prior versions).
If you chose to be inclusive and retro-compatible, you can't seriously consider 2e as a starting point, as it excludes everything prior 2e from your inclusiveness )