Green Arrow or Hawkeye?

[Water Bob]

Which do you like better? DC's Green Arrow or Marvel's Hawkeye?

 

[Dannyalcatraz]

I've gone back & forth on that. I think I like them about equally...what they're not too campy.

 

[Kramodlog]

There is no "they both leave me indifferent" option and no "both are awesome" option.

 

[Morrus]

Problem with Green Arrow is he wishes he was Batman. He's got the fortune, the company, the cave, and the sidekick. But Batman's costume is cooler.

 

[Water Bob]

Yep, batman has the better costume. But, I've seen some cool renderings of Green Arrow, like this one...prety neat.

 

[Crothian]

After seeing Green Arrow in the Brave and the Bold it really made me a Green Arrow fan. Sure there is a lot of campy stuff in the comics but I think the best Green Arrow comics are better then the best Hawkeye comics of what I have read.

 

[trappedslider]

Problem with Green Arrow is he wishes he was Batman. He's got the fortune, the company, the cave, and the sidekick. But Batman's costume is cooler.

Considering GA was created to be like Batman...The Arrowcar, Arrowsignal, Arrowcave.....it got to the point where even Batman asks, "Did you ever have an original idea?"


EDIT:

After seeing Green Arrow in the Brave and the Bold it really made me a Green Arrow fan.

I like GA's appearance in the JLU cartoon...he hums his own theme tune!

 

[billd91]

They both have their good points. Hawkeye was Goliath for a while, is hot-headed and brash, and used to hang out with 19th century cowboy-heroes. Green Lantern is hot-headed and blunt, isn't afraid to take on social justice issues, and hangs (or used to hang) around with a hot ass-kicking woman in fishnets. Who can choose?!?

They've also both been rebooted/re-envisioned in very interesting ways too. I really liked the Ultimates take on Hawkeye and Arrow has been a fun TV show to watch.

 

[sabrinathecat]

Yeah, the question is "What version".
JLU Green Arrow was good.
Arrow was interesting.
B&B GA was the same problem as the rest of B&B: campy.

Hawkeye from Comics was good.
Hawkeye from A:EMH was fun.
Hawkeye from recent movies: boring beyond belief, and utterly devoid of character. Cardboard cut-out.