Mando season 3

Holy crap! Episode 2 really delivers. That was fantastic!
That was certainly a huge improvement, particularly in that the episode actually had a subject, a focus, themes, a story, and so on.

Some spoiler-filled observations:

1) What is Mando's "major malfunction" re: the Darksaber? Like, before it was clear he was unpracticed with it, but it's been, according to Favreau, like two years, and the dude is still inept with it. I don't know if I'd even be strong enough to lift it, but assuming I could, I stone-cold guarantee, I, Ruin Explorer, would be a better Darksaber fighter than bloody Mando relatively quickly, simply because I'd spend a few days or a week practicing with the damn thing! (Assuming I didn't lose a limb in the process) Even if you didn't know how it worked inertia/weight-wise at the start, you would after ten hours or whatever, and then it'd be a matter of training yourself.

I do feel like at least it's consistent enough that this is some kind of characterization - either that Din isn't very sensible as a warrior, and doesn't practice or try to learn new things, or that he's just innately bad with the Darksaber, and will never be good with it, because he's not meant to wield it.

2) If the latter, what we saw was very interesting, because Bo Katan was an absolute effortless total badass with it, kicking the ass of the power armour/cyborg which attacked them like she was a Jedi Master with a lightsaber. She was clearly is trained with it (which I believe we know from Clone Wars/Rebels) and possibly also born to it.

3) Bo Katan generally made a pretty good case for being "the real Mandalorian" here, hope Din was paying some damn attention. I'm actually feeling kind of sorry for Din at this point, because his naivete is really causing him issues.

4) Bo Katan also was the only one to actually see the Mythosaur (one presumes, given Din appeared to be unconscious), which seems pretty omen-y.

5) Grogu is absolutely clearly now fully sentient and just non-verbal. He's at least as smart as a 6/7-year-old or so, and with a lot more emotional maturity than most. I mean, we already kind of new that, but it's now unarguable.

6) The power armour driven by the cyborg was fascinating. Primarily it seemed extremely Rifts-esque, which is interesting because Rifts was always heavily Star Wars influenced (among many others), though it most resembled a Tachikoma from Ghost In The Shell. The cyborg driving it had massive Doctor Who vibes too, and just really seemed perfectly that sort of '80s "grotesque cyborg" deal we used to see a lot. The head detaching and skittering away is something I've seen before but am having difficulty placing. Probably in a '80s movie or cartoon? Or 2000 AD. Or Rifts, actually.

Anyway, yes, much better episode. More like this.
 

log in or register to remove this ad




I am also glad they seem to have abandoned the idea of restoring IG-11, which seemed a bit much IMO, and cheapened IG-11's sacrifice.
You know the weirdest damn thing about this show?

It's like it has an entire room full of writers, with disagreeing ideas, because of the way ideas seem to be important then suddenly dropped - but there's only one writer for the vast majority of the episodes (usually 6 out of 8 per season), and that's Jon Favreau. I don't hate it but it's a bit weird though I am glad to see that plotline go.
 


Theory: "Mandalorian" (in the show title) refers to Grogu, not Din Djarin.
I think the show kind of signposted that with the speech Din gave to Grogu near the start of the episode. Remains to be seen whether it's a misdirect or not though, because honestly there was also the bit where:

Bo Katan pointed out she was more of a Mandalorian than Din by far, and that was immediately after showing she was awesome with the Darksaber, and immediately before saving Din from his own stupidity and before she, not Din or Grogu, saw the Mythosaur.
 


That was certainly a huge improvement, particularly in that the episode actually had a subject, a focus, themes, a story, and so on.

Some spoiler-filled observations:

1) What is Mando's "major malfunction" re: the Darksaber? Like, before it was clear he was unpracticed with it, but it's been, according to Favreau, like two years, and the dude is still inept with it. I don't know if I'd even be strong enough to lift it, but assuming I could, I stone-cold guarantee, I, Ruin Explorer, would be a better Darksaber fighter than bloody Mando relatively quickly, simply because I'd spend a few days or a week practicing with the damn thing! (Assuming I didn't lose a limb in the process) Even if you didn't know how it worked inertia/weight-wise at the start, you would after ten hours or whatever, and then it'd be a matter of training yourself.

I do feel like at least it's consistent enough that this is some kind of characterization - either that Din isn't very sensible as a warrior, and doesn't practice or try to learn new things, or that he's just innately bad with the Darksaber, and will never be good with it, because he's not meant to wield it.

2) If the latter, what we saw was very interesting, because Bo Katan was an absolute effortless total badass with it, kicking the ass of the power armour/cyborg which attacked them like she was a Jedi Master with a lightsaber. She was clearly is trained with it (which I believe we know from Clone Wars/Rebels) and possibly also born to it.

3) Bo Katan generally made a pretty good case for being "the real Mandalorian" here, hope Din was paying some damn attention. I'm actually feeling kind of sorry for Din at this point, because his naivete is really causing him issues.

4) Bo Katan also was the only one to actually see the Mythosaur (one presumes, given Din appeared to be unconscious), which seems pretty omen-y.

5) Grogu is absolutely clearly now fully sentient and just non-verbal. He's at least as smart as a 6/7-year-old or so, and with a lot more emotional maturity than most. I mean, we already kind of new that, but it's now unarguable.

6) The power armour driven by the cyborg was fascinating. Primarily it seemed extremely Rifts-esque, which is interesting because Rifts was always heavily Star Wars influenced (among many others), though it most resembled a Tachikoma from Ghost In The Shell. The cyborg driving it had massive Doctor Who vibes too, and just really seemed perfectly that sort of '80s "grotesque cyborg" deal we used to see a lot. The head detaching and skittering away is something I've seen before but am having difficulty placing. Probably in a '80s movie or cartoon? Or 2000 AD. Or Rifts, actually.

Anyway, yes, much better episode. More like this.
Regarding Din and the darksaber, it's worth re-watching the Rebels episode where Sabine learns to wield it (S3 E15). She also struggles with it, and the Jedi training her aren't surprised - there seems to be a degree of mental connection required for any light saber to be wielded well.

Din hasn't had the benefit of Jedi training and he just plain doesn't think about the weapon that way, so it's no wonder he struggles with it.

Regarding the episode in general, yes this was a great improvement. I really liked seeing Din's journey to the surface first and then Bo's. The clear difference in emotional impact between them was a great contrast, and this was, in general, very much more Bo Katan's episode than Din Djarin's.

Did anyone else immediately think "Morlocks" when those creatures ambushed Din?
 

I am also glad they seem to have abandoned the idea of restoring IG-11, which seemed a bit much IMO, and cheapened IG-11's sacrifice.
They didn't abandon the idea. Mando is going to search for the necessary part to fix IG-11.

EDIT: Oops, I haven't watched episode 2 yet, and I'm basing my comment off of episode 1. I'm going to ignore this thread until I've had a chance to watch this week's episode!
 

Remove ads

Top