Paul Farquhar
Legend
There is an almost identical scene in Treasure Island where Silver holds a knife to Jim Hawkins’ throat. And a similar scene where he convinces the pirates to follow him to get the treasure rather than mutiny. Silver develops paternal feelings towards the kid, but doesn’t really stop being a scoundrel.He doesn't seem to be a total bad guy. Sure, he ordered the acid trap to be reset, which was meant to kill every bounty hunter/pirate, in cold blood. But he obviously had reservation when fighting "Captain" Fern