2006 WotC D&D Product Survivor - Round 16 (Final 3)

[Glyfair]

As expected, Complete Mage left us last round. We are down to the final 3. This round will determine the final showdown.

 

[heirodule]

I love all three products, and PHII has a fair ammount of dross, but the Fiendlish codexes both loose out for me because they failed to reprint or create any new thrall prestige classes from Vile Darkness. I don't wanna ever buy vile darkness, but I want thrall prcs.

The hells book got marginal props over the abyss because of the new player race, which I like.

PHBII for the win!

 

[sckeener]

Long live the Obyrith! From the Abyss they shall rule!

Pleasure devils, on your knees!

and kiss the PHB2 bye bye.

 

[MerricB]

I think PH2 may go, just because the Fiendish Codexes split the vote.

 

[Shade]

PHBII, you are a fantastic, watershed book, but alas, you don't intrigue me from cover to cover.

 

[Crothian]

I can't believe that the Fiendish codexes are both still here. They are not all that great.

 

[MerricB]

I can't believe that the Fiendish codexes are both still here. They are not all that great.

They split the vote. Someone who votes for one probably could have quite easily have voted for another. Add their votes together, and we'll see which round they could have been voted off in...

Cheers!

 

[Felix]

I can't believe that the Fiendish codexes are both still here. They are not all that great.

They split the vote. Someone who votes for one probably could have quite easily have voted for another. Add their votes together, and we'll see which round they could have been voted off in...

The same thing happened in the Core Religion Survivor; Hextor and Heironeous, who were not liked by that many people, ended up #1 and #2 because the vote was split on people's dislike. Vote splitting between two substitutes is a serious flaw in Survivor-style voting systems. Unless you favor one of the vote-splitters, in which case it's a virtue.

 

[Psion]

They split the vote. Someone who votes for one probably could have quite easily have voted for another. Add their votes together, and we'll see which round they could have been voted off in...

But is it fair to do so? One is better than the other, after all...

 

[MerricB]

But is it fair to do so? One is better than the other, after all...

I really wonder how many people have seen FC2, and are judging it on FC1. (I know I haven't got FC2 yet...)

Cheers!