D&D General Are you jumping ship? What will you be switching to?

What system will you switch to?

  • Pathfinder

    Votes: 60 42.3%
  • Fantasy AGE

    Votes: 7 4.9%
  • The One Ring

    Votes: 11 7.7%
  • Dungeon World/PbtA

    Votes: 11 7.7%
  • FATE

    Votes: 10 7.0%
  • Cortex

    Votes: 2 1.4%
  • Genesys

    Votes: 4 2.8%
  • Cypher

    Votes: 9 6.3%
  • Other (please specify)

    Votes: 100 70.4%
  • SotDL/SotWW

    Votes: 12 8.5%


log in or register to remove this ad


SAVeira

Adventurer
No plans to jump ship. Already play multiple systems. No need to abandon my current D&D game. That would very much a throwing the baby out with the bathwater situation.
 

HaroldTheHobbit

Adventurer
You can't go wrong with Masks. Which version are you using? They came out with a truly massive, massive expansion version of Masks a few years ago. If interested, you can read the recap on my blog here:



This is the new revised edition. I would use this one if I ran it again, but I don't have time to invest a couple years into the same story, so I would personally go with Serpent for Pulp Cthulhu.


I have the recent slipcased version of Masks (amazing product!) and will run it for my players starting sometime during 2024.
 

The only WotC product I would have considered buying in the foreseeable future is a new Dark Sun book. Even then I'd most likely port it to another system.

I genuinely wonder if we're going to hit a point where playing 5e/OneD&D/etc. is stigmatized. Not just by long-time haters like me, but by a bigger portion of the hobby. Once certain brands become toxic enough (Big Tobacco, Facebook, etc) they never really recover. They can still make money, for sure, but not like they used to.
 


Bupp

Adventurer
I currently think I'll be jumping ship, though I'm currently in "wait and see" mode.

I'm curious about what MCDM and Kobold Press have in store (love the balls of them calling it Project Black Flag).

Since I like some genre bending in my D&D, I'm currently looking at Worlds Without Number and Dungeon World (for that Powered by the Apocalypse flavor).
 

Hillarious to me are the people who are abandoning D&D to play a game that only exists because of the OGL license. Whether you CHOOSE not to purchase new D&D books, or CAN'T purchase new Pathfinder/DCC/OSE books, you're gonna be reliant on your ingenuity to expand the game.
And the problem with that is?

OK, I'm an old-timer, who started playing in 1979. But the concept of DMs who need published adventures is a bit surprising to me.
 

Vaalingrade

Legend
Man, it sure is weird people are choosing to support a thing that's being assailed in protest against the assailants. Just an absolute kneeslapper. Move over Cedric the Entertainer, the basic concept of protest is the new king of comedy.
 

Grunadler

Explorer
My Cypher System library takes up most of my gaming shelves. My 5e game running over 2yrs will continue (we don't use DDB) and it is a Homebrew. Most of my 5e library is actually 3rd party books. Looking forward to Mothership, as well.
 


The-Magic-Sword

Small Ball Archmage
I jumped ship to Pathfinder on Second Edition's release (you see me around here mostly for the General DND type conversations that have the overlap), looking at the poll, welcome to the potential new people to my fave system?
 
Last edited:

I jumped ship to Pathfinder on Second Edition's release (see see me around here mostly for the General DND type conversations that have the overlap), looking at the poll, welcome to the potential new people to my fave system?

Not exactly a surprise that the top result for switching from 5e is the most 5e-like of all presented options. DCC and OSE aren't even up there. Did you expect a sudden spike in Dungeon World interest?
 

The-Magic-Sword

Small Ball Archmage
Not exactly a surprise that the top result for switching from 5e is the most 5e-like of all presented options. DCC and OSE aren't even up there. Did you expect a sudden spike in Dungeon World interest?
I'm not OP, but I actually expected more representation for just about every option on the poll-- a subset of people running for a slew of PBTA games, Cortex, Fate, etc.

I actually happened to buy OSE Advanced Fantasy literally five minutes before you mentioned it though, funny enough, it would never be a full switch due to my group's tastes but I've been wanting to try some OSR as a novelty and for educational reasons, I actually had DCC from a humble bundle somewhere here as well.
 

I'm not going D&D 5E again without a pretty serious climbdown, and it's honestly a pity, because I was intending to run a Shadow of the Dragonlords campaign and come back to 5E after I'd stopped for a year or so.

I'm not sure what I'll run instead. Keep going with Spire for sure for now but I did want to do some epic fantasy. Hmph.
 


Fenris-77

Small God of the Dozens
Supporter
I'm not going D&D 5E again without a pretty serious climbdown, and it's honestly a pity, because I was intending to run a Shadow of the Dragonlords campaign and come back to 5E after I'd stopped for a year or so.

I'm not sure what I'll run instead. Keep going with Spire for sure for now but I did want to do some epic fantasy. Hmph.
Just run it with a different system.(y)
 


Citizen Mane

The Kajamba Lion
I'm about to be playing in a Pathfinder 2e game. If I were running a fantasy game, it'd either be one of the older editions of D&D (1st, 3rd), Warhammer Fantasy 2e, Swords of the Serpentine, Burning Wheel, or Torchbearer 2e. Then again, I'm not so much jumping ship as finally getting onboard again.
 

Haplo781

Legend
The only WotC product I would have considered buying in the foreseeable future is a new Dark Sun book. Even then I'd most likely port it to another system.

I genuinely wonder if we're going to hit a point where playing 5e/OneD&D/etc. is stigmatized. Not just by long-time haters like me, but by a bigger portion of the hobby. Once certain brands become toxic enough (Big Tobacco, Facebook, etc) they never really recover. They can still make money, for sure, but not like they used to.
If you want a Dark Sun book to port to another system just get the 4e one.
 

Epic Threats

An Advertisement

Advertisement4

Top