• NOW LIVE! Into the Woods--new character species, eerie monsters, and haunting villains to populate the woodlands of your D&D games.

CODENAME: MORNINGSTAR - Is This The End, Or Is There More To Come?

With just two days to go, the controversial Kickstarter for Codename: Morningstar is closing in on its end, and with only 16% of its funding goal achieved at the time of writing, it doesn't seem likely to succeed unless something changes over the weekend. The last full update from the developers on the Kickstarter page was on December 23rd, nearly two weeks ago. However, they have been making comments recently which contain some hints at future plans.

They say "The end of the Kickstarter doesn't necessarily signify the end for us. We'll see what the new year brings!" which hints that they won't be giving up completely, as their recent statement that "...if there does not appear to be a sufficient market interest our continued investment in the gaming industry is not assured" implied. So, even if the Kickstarter fails, it sounds like there are other plans in motion.

[lq]The end of the Kickstarter doesn't necessarily signify the end for us. We'll see what the new year brings![/lq]

The Kickstarter has actually raised $70,000 so far which, if not compared to the high initial goal of $425,000, is actually a really good showing. Nearly 1,200 people have shown positive interest and support by pledging money, so there is a support base there. With a bit of regrouping, Codename: Morningstar could still come to fruition. As they themselves say, "...one thing we've found is there are a large number of people who won't be convinced that we're doing something special until they actually see it. We're working on how to make that happen." In other words, any future approach will likely involve potential customers actually being able to see the product firsthand. Additionally, they mention that have "been working on a radical plan behind the scenes on how to price the Forge [component of C:M]", so there may be some new information on that soon.

With all that in mind, and with the end of the Kickstarter closing in, Trapdoor has posted a new "story update", which is their metaphorical way of talking about their progress:

"Newtonian smiles as he brushes the snow from his cloak. The heat from the pub's old stone hearth is pleasing, but the sheer number of friends and supporters tucked into every chair in the room warms his heart. He had been nervous when the decision was made to use Nowell's magic to return home for help. With only three days left in their quest, it seems that the Trickster's riddle will go unsolved. The rogue had feared they would not be welcomed home having failed to retrieve their magical tools before the holidays. He worried that the dream of the Crystal Tome of Storytelling would be lost. Now, as he looks over the room - the community pouring over possible solutions to the puzzle, discussing alternate routes over the mountains - Newtonian realizes this is just the first step of the journey. Determination and belief can be seen on each face. There are some tears, that's for sure, but there are no signs of surrender. Hobo, carrying a tray stacked impossibly high with beer tankards, weaves her way through the crowds - handing out frothing mugs of cheer and goodwill. Newtonian shakes his head, marveling at her resilience. A quick glance out the window shows the stars dimming as the sun begins to rise. Nowell's magic will end soon, and the adventurers of the Trapdoor Forge and Magicworks will face the final decision for solving the Trickster's puzzle. "Hurry, friends," he shouts. "Time is drawing near. The odds are impossible, but put everything you can into this final push. The story must be told!" Cinereus summons a quick volley of fireworks which fill the room with light and sound. Cups raised, a cheer goes up - one last toast to the effort, "To Morningstar!"


[video=youtube;JZRsap1TUq0]https://www.youtube.com/watch?feature=player_embedded&v=JZRsap1TUq0[/video]
 

log in or register to remove this ad

Grimstaff chuckles as he exits the tavern, closing the door softly so as not to disturb the revelers he leaves behind. "All has come to be as I have foreseen," he mutters to himself with a wry smile somewhere between chagrin and regret. As he takes the few shallow steps from the door down to the street, his knapsack slaps against his thigh, comforting with the weight of the well-used spell book within. As he passes up the street and into the shadows a trio of cutpurses scuttles back into their hiding places, knowing this is no mere Illusionist that passes close by, but a true Mage.
 

If they had a goal of $100,000, I would guess they might actually make it. $70,000 for a project that obviously wasn't going to fund is pretty good. But would that be enough?
 



I am annoyed with a lot of the comments that have come out of Trapdoor. Stating that if people do not back it then we are ok with the status quo. NO I am not going to fund something that I have no use for with the chance WotC will make an OGL for 5e use. That is a big if. They failed to launch the 5e version and that is bad on them. When I said I had no use for it on Twitter they responded (which was cool of them) that they hopeful for the OGL but I should kick in a dollar anyway. (That was not cool)

They should have stuck with JUST the character builder and given the gaming community confidence in their plan instead of us footing a huge portion of their development tool for Pathfinder. Screw that mess.
 

I am annoyed with a lot of the comments that have come out of Trapdoor. Stating that if people do not back it then we are ok with the status quo. NO I am not going to fund something that I have no use for with the chance WotC will make an OGL for 5e use. That is a big if. They failed to launch the 5e version and that is bad on them. When I said I had no use for it on Twitter they responded (which was cool of them) that they hopeful for the OGL but I should kick in a dollar anyway. (That was not cool)

They should have stuck with JUST the character builder and given the gaming community confidence in their plan instead of us footing a huge portion of their development tool for Pathfinder. Screw that mess.

I'm not a lawyer... or a copyright guy... or maybe even a really smart guy, but if companies can useold ogl to make adventures, could someone do basic character creation? I mean that seems to be what brass city is doing...
 


Well, I suppose they could just go back to their equally vague e-publishing business.

But, since they tried to get away from that into D&D tools, I imagine that wasn't going gangbusters for them.
Really... yeah, this is probably the end for Morningstar. The company is too big for a group with no product or revenue stream. They have too many people sucking down paycheques for Morningstar to ever really get them in the black, not when they need to make a million dollars each year to support their staff.
 
Last edited by a moderator:


Into the Woods

Remove ads

Into the Woods

Remove ads

Top