Whaddya mean, exactly? Per person? From amongst the loot we uncovered? Or something else?
Frex, Warren would normally have a use for one of those short swords, but it'd put him into medium encumbrance since it's not a Small short sword like the one he already uses. He'd also take a penalty on attack rolls with it, given the size difference. Still, if you do mean choosing from amongst the loot recovered, then Warren would choose one of the short swords.
If you mean otherwise, Warren would really,
really like to find a Handy Haversack sometime, so he can carry his gear and any further loot in it!

His puny halfling arms and pecs are no good at carrying stuff, so he's almost burdened as-is with his modest provisions and assorted weaponry (bow, dagger, sword, and club).