• NOW LIVE! Into the Woods--new character species, eerie monsters, and haunting villains to populate the woodlands of your D&D games.

D&D 5E D&D 5e death and consequences?

Remember, it is the DM setting up the encounter that resulted in the PC death in the first place. Some portion of the responsibility for that PC death has to be taken by the DM who created the encounter and decided NPC actions during that encounter. For example, if 4 NPC archers fire at the PC wizard and the PC wizard dies, why exactly is the DM then further punishing the player of that PC?

This is just as heavy handed by a DM as some adventure railroading sometimes is.


:lol:


Just a sec....

:lol:

Wow. Thats a good one.

There was a monster in there! We HAD to charge in and fight it. The DM made us!!!!

This only makes sense if the players are led around by the nose and told whom to fight, and where and when.

As a player, if you put up with that then the PC wasn't really yours to control anyway so who cares if it dies?
 

log in or register to remove this ad


Err, yeah it does. Page 227 of the PHB. Can't do the teleport trick because Teleport is a 7th-level spell and Contingency is limited to 5th or lower, but the Contingency spell is definitely in 5e.

Odd. I purposely went off and looked for it a few weeks back. Blind as well as old. :erm:
 

Err, yeah it does. Page 227 of the PHB. Can't do the teleport trick because Teleport is a 7th-level spell and Contingency is limited to 5th or lower, but the Contingency spell is definitely in 5e.

Odd. I purposely went off and looked for it a few weeks back. Blind as well as old. :erm:
 



Two things no one mentioned all thread...

One, the gutting of the reincarnation table. You always come back as a humanoid. No more 15th level Berserker Badgers ;_;

Two, 8th level Transmuter Wizards can also bring back the dead iirc, it's the chePest res in the game.

My own thoughts...

RAW returning from the dead is pretty easy. However each time it happens a diamond is destroyed, while it's not that uncommon a stone after a few thousand years they're probably getting a little thin on the ground. In theory this means smaller and smaller diamonds should become valuable enough to use, but D&d seems to run on aristotelian economics so maybe not.

However it's basically impossible to concieve that the diamond trade would not be heavily regulated. In heavy handed regimes private ownership of diamonds would probably be illegal, with exorbitant smuggling being the logical consequence. That might lead to fun scenarios where the PCs bring in a stone to raise Fred the fighter but the priests swap it for a hunk of quartz so they can res St Localboy, who died last week. Hijinks ensue.

Yeah diamond trade wars would be about as high stakes as you can get. Fun times.

Something I wonder about though. If reincarnation is a thing, doesn't that mean that after Joe has been dead for a certain time period that ressurecting him causes someone, somewhere to drop dead? Is this moral?
 

RAW returning from the dead is pretty easy. However each time it happens a diamond is destroyed, while it's not that uncommon a stone after a few thousand years they're probably getting a little thin on the ground. In theory this means smaller and smaller diamonds should become valuable enough to use, but D&d seems to run on aristotelian economics so maybe not.

However it's basically impossible to concieve that the diamond trade would not be heavily regulated. In heavy handed regimes private ownership of diamonds would probably be illegal, with exorbitant smuggling being the logical consequence.
Won't exorbitant smuggling just reduce the size/quality of 500 gp diamonds?
 


RAW returning from the dead is pretty easy. However each time it happens a diamond is destroyed, while it's not that uncommon a stone after a few thousand years they're probably getting a little thin on the ground. In theory this means smaller and smaller diamonds should become valuable enough to use, but D&d seems to run on aristotelian economics so maybe not.
The gods demand a certain market value of diamonds not a weight or quality. People got smart long ago and decided that a few grains of diamond dust are worth 500GP so there is enough to rez all you want for the next few million years.
 

Into the Woods

Remove ads

Top