D&D 5E Dungeonscape Lives!

[Jackal2100]

They also have another interview here. http://therpgacademy.com/table-topics-episode-65-michael-interviews-chris-matney/. This one adds in more detail about the product by the head of the company. It is a lot more than a character builder, and that is just the first thing that people saw.

 

[Nylanfs]

And they also can't talk about who they are pursuing until the damn deal is done. That is standard business practices.

 

[trancejeremy]

So maybe they shouldn't be hyping something then, if they can't talk about it? All they are doing is generating ill will.

Look at the reaction to this on reddit
http://www.reddit.com/r/rpg/comments/2o9p9g/exclusive_the_death_of_dungeonscape_trapdoors/

Mostly ignored, but what reaction there is, it's negative.

http://www.reddit.com/r/DnD/comments/2o70pf/trapdoor_technologies_officially_announce/

Non-amazingly they don't ever says what they are going to be doing, just like dungeonscape never really said what it was going to be.

But at least they have every confidence they can pull it off. Whatever that is.

 

[Jackal2100]

Again, the second interview with Chris Matney goes into much greater detail into what the actual thing does.

 

[casterblaster]

Maybe this thread should be moved if they can't or won't support 5e? I could care less actually but the way they are going about this feels all wrong.

 

[GMforPowergamers]

Maybe this thread should be moved if they can't or won't support 5e? I could care less actually but the way they are going about this feels all wrong.

could not agree more, this is no longer a 5e thread...

 

[ZombieRoboNinja]

could not agree more, this is no longer a 5e thread...

Yeah, move it to the forum for Unnamed Secret Game That You Should Totally Care About Because it Has A Good Character Builder If We Kickstart It.

 

[Ramius613]

Wow, they honestly sound like they have their heads up their butts. They seem to really think that people are "fans of Project Morningstar" rather than fans of a good tool for whatever game they're playing. Are they seriously trying to promo a character builder without mentioning the dang game system it's for? I don't care how shiny the stat selection is, I'm not going to go buy and read a thousand pages of Pathfinder books (or whatever) to have the opportunity to use it.

Do you know what Morningstar is besides just being a character builder that they admitted was poorly designed for the web and Android interface?

 

[fjw70]

Any word on their kickstarter yet?

 

[Dausuul]

My problem is why people aren't more outraged that one again Wizards took their toys and went home.

Bluntly put, I'm not outraged because the Dungeonscape beta was disastrous. It was crawling with bugs that should have been shaken out during internal testing long before anything was released to the public. Maybe the iOS version was better, but what we saw on the web was abysmal. If that was the quality of their work, I'd have cut ties with them too.

Moreover, what were they offering that we were supposed to be so excited for? A character builder? I can get a dozen of those on the web for free. Not only that, but 5E makes it easy to build a character by hand again--much easier than either 3E or 4E--so a character builder has to really blow me away before I start getting excited. Even pretending the bugs weren't there, Dungeonscape didn't show me anything that other character builders hadn't done before just as well.

It doesn't help that the Trapdoor guys keep trying to work us up with breathless, substance-free hype. I'm working on a little 5E gadget of my own--an encounter builder and combat tracker--and I happen to think it's got some pretty neat features, but I'm not under any delusions that the whole Internet is just waiting breathlessly to hear me announce it. If I want anybody to use my app*, I'm going to have to pitch them on specific reasons why it's better than what they've got now, not just bloviate about how wonderful my app is.

[SIZE=-2]*Always assuming we get some sort of licensing scheme that allows it to see the light of day. If not, it'll be just me and my group using it.[/SIZE]