Clint_L
Legend
Valid points. I always did up the bases on my Warhammer miniatures, as 90% of the time we were playing on my homemade battle boards, so I could match them pretty much exactly, and it looked amazing. Nowadays it's mostly RPGs (the above miniatures came with a board game but I am planning to use them in the new Arkham Horror RPG). So sometimes they'll be in woods, or a creepy old house, or city streets, icy cavern, etc.Yes, this is an eternal question and any right answer is subjective. I wargamed for many years on many types of terrain, at different stores and people's homes and grand tournaments.
For me, finished bases not matching the terrain are still always more aesthetically pleasing than plain black bases. And my experience with transparent bases is that they typically scratch easily and become cloudy, and that they're too smooth and slide excessively on uneven terrain.
Ultimately, though, I'm pretty agnostic about bases - all of my Reaper ones come with skateboards, for example, and D&L miniatures have fully sculpted bases, so you're kind of stuck with what you get.