Except there was a looooong discussion, followed by a tweet from JC that state otherwise.
-
NOW LIVE! Into the Woods--new character species, eerie monsters, and haunting villains to populate the woodlands of your D&D games.
D&D 5E Have Scorching Ray and eldritch blast been nerfed somehow with charisma?
- Thread starter maraxion
- Start date
CapnZapp
Legend
But what is the tweet?
Look. Having EB blasts be one after the other doesn't make sense, given how the spell is written. Are you sure it wasn't about repelling blast?
I can definitely see Crawford responding in the context of repelling blast pushing you out of the range. Using that tweet to infer that EB fire off blasts in order is getting way outside his intention.
But.
We can't get any further without the tweet. It's no good basing your ruling on a tweet we can't read and discuss...
Uh no, you're talking nonsense. Agonizing Blast and Repelling Blast are both applied to the same spell. If repelling blast is sequential, agonizing blast must also be sequential.
CapnZapp
Legend
You really need to link the tweet at this point
http://www.sageadvice.eu/?s=repelling+blast
Under "Warlock Repelling Blast"
Under "Warlock Repelling Blast"
Helldritch
Hero
So everything stack...
Thx for the link.
Still think EB is over powered.
Thx for the link.
Still think EB is over powered.
Greenstone.Walker
Adventurer
For multiple bolt/blast/ray spells, you should resolve the attack for the first blast/ray/whatever before declaring the target of the next.
Magic missile specifically says "The darts all strike simultaneously", which defines the normal behaviour for spells such as eldritch blast and scorching ray to be striking sequentially. Additionally, Crawford's tweet about repelling blast pushing a target out of range of further bolts lends weight to the sequential behaviour.
An archer with Extra Attack (level 10) can shoot 3 arrows, at one, two or three targets. All 3 attacks have DEX added to the damage. The attacks are made sequentially by the player (e.g. if the first arrow kills the first target, the archer doesn't have to waste any more arrows on a downed foe).
I'm also fine with adding the CHA/Elemental/whatever damage bonus to each ray. regardless of the number of targets, though the errata specifies that this is not the case for Draconic Sorcerer elemental affinity.
Since there is a chance of a miss, adding the CHA modifier to each bolt, even if multiple bolts hit the same target, seems fair to me. After all, the archer gets to add their DEX mod 3 times to damage, even if all 3 arrows hit the same target.
Area of effect spells are different. In that case, there is no attack roll because all targets in range get automatically hit (with a saving throw to reduce or negate damage). In that case, the ability score modifier gets added once to the damage value that applies to everyone.
If you compare it to a magic longbow or crossbow, it's not quite as powerful as it seems. Still powerful, but then again, it is the primary ranged attack of a warlock.
Magic missile specifically says "The darts all strike simultaneously", which defines the normal behaviour for spells such as eldritch blast and scorching ray to be striking sequentially. Additionally, Crawford's tweet about repelling blast pushing a target out of range of further bolts lends weight to the sequential behaviour.
An archer with Extra Attack (level 10) can shoot 3 arrows, at one, two or three targets. All 3 attacks have DEX added to the damage. The attacks are made sequentially by the player (e.g. if the first arrow kills the first target, the archer doesn't have to waste any more arrows on a downed foe).
I'm also fine with adding the CHA/Elemental/whatever damage bonus to each ray. regardless of the number of targets, though the errata specifies that this is not the case for Draconic Sorcerer elemental affinity.
Since there is a chance of a miss, adding the CHA modifier to each bolt, even if multiple bolts hit the same target, seems fair to me. After all, the archer gets to add their DEX mod 3 times to damage, even if all 3 arrows hit the same target.
Area of effect spells are different. In that case, there is no attack roll because all targets in range get automatically hit (with a saving throw to reduce or negate damage). In that case, the ability score modifier gets added once to the damage value that applies to everyone.
If you compare it to a magic longbow or crossbow, it's not quite as powerful as it seems. Still powerful, but then again, it is the primary ranged attack of a warlock.
Last edited:
Similar Threads
