Arts Briefing
By LAWRENCE VAN GELDER
Published: March 4, 2004
IGHLIGHTS
FILM: 'HIDALGO' vs. THE NAYSAYERS Disney's Touchstone Pictures says its $80 million action-adventure film "Hidalgo," opening tomorrow, is based on a true story. But some experts say the film, about an American named Frank T. Hopkins riding his mustang, Hidalgo, in a 3,000-mile endurance race against 100 Bedouin horsemen and their Arab steeds across the Arabian desert in 1890, is pure fiction. "Hidalgo," directed by Joe Johnston ("Honey, I Shrunk the Kids," "Jumanji," "Jurassic Park III") and written by John Fusco ("Crossroads," "Young Guns"), stars Viggo Mortensen, above, as Hopkins and Omar Sharif as Sheik Riyadh, who invites him to compete in the race, called the Ocean of Fire. Discussing Hopkins's book "Hidalgo and Other Stories," horsetravelbooks.com, the Web site of HorseTravelBooks, a division of the Long Riders Guild Press, refers to research by more than 70 experts in 5 countries, "ranging from the curator of the Buffalo Bill Museum to the former Sultan of Yemen."It"revealed that Hopkins had maintained a spirited disregard for the truth, plagiarized material from famous authors, slandered genuine American heroes and perpetrated a massive fraud for nearly 100 years." An article in The Arab News, the Saudi Arabian English-language Middle East daily that lays claim to being the first newspaper to question the historical basis of "Hidalgo," quotes Dr. Awad Al-Badi, an authority on Western travelers to Arabia, as saying, "The idea of a trans-Arabian horse race ever having been run is pure nonsense." The article says that a 3,000-mile race beginning in Aden and run in a straight line would end somewhere in Romania, and a route around the coast of Arabia would put the finish line north of Armenia. Discussing the criticism of "Hidalgo," Dennis Rice, senior vice president for publicity of the Walt Disney Studios, who called the movie "factually based," said yesterday: "We want to make sure that everybody knows we haven't made a documentary. It's very much a Hollywood `popcorn' movie." He continued, "We believe that we made a movie based on the life of Frank T. Hopkins, and we stand behind the screenwriter."