Doctor Proctor
First Post
How to defeat that monster: Head for nearest cover. Run if you must. Force it into situations where its flying is no advantage. From cover and concealment, have ranged attacker take potshots. Your fighters and paladins should have them, it's called a bow. Every character should have a ranged attack, even if it's 'suboptimal.' Having NO ranged attack is truly suboptimal, because of situations like this. Force the dragon to fight on -your- terms.
As I mentioned above, the consensus before seemed to be that a DM unleashing an encounter like this wouldn't let you run and hide easily. Additionally, why should my Fighter carry a Bow unless he knows that he's going to be facing something that can hit from 20 squares away? I don't really have any points in Dex, and neither does our Paladin. So not only would we be operating at a -4 when compared to our Ranger, but we'd be at range to boot. I suppose we might hit the thing 10% of the time or something...
Plus, I usually have Handaxes as it fits my character better. They're heavy thrown, so I can use Strength, and I've got a high Con and usually only use Axes as my melee weapon of choice. So again, unless I knew ahead of time what we were facing (Which would either break the 4th wall, or allow us to make sure that the Dragon wasn't in the open when we went after it) I wouldn't do anything different.