dcollins:
Who decides who is an "enemy"?
The provoker of the AoO?
--If so, I could consider myself an ally of the troll and not incur AoO's as I run past him.
The person who threatens the provoker?
--If so, the rogue gets his AoO.
The omnicient DM?
--If so, players no longer have free will and this discussion about who is an enemy or an ally is meaningless.
The RAW?
--If so... Citation?
Who decides who is an "enemy"?
The provoker of the AoO?
--If so, I could consider myself an ally of the troll and not incur AoO's as I run past him.
The person who threatens the provoker?
--If so, the rogue gets his AoO.
The omnicient DM?
--If so, players no longer have free will and this discussion about who is an enemy or an ally is meaningless.
The RAW?
--If so... Citation?