Midnight or AU

[blindrage]

I vote Midnight. Lower learning curve for you and your players and there are few sites out for Midnights with ideas for games.

 

[Nightfall]

Not to mention the fact them Night King fellows aren't exactly eager to have some wannabe heroes parading around their turf.

 

[Nightfall]

Buy both. Use both. I'm going for that ideal. Besides I promised Ash if I supported his Sage cause he'd make sure to get a deity named for me some day.

Hey I just happen to think a god named Nightfall is cool.

 

[ES2]

Hey I just happen to think a god named Nightfall is cool.

I might worship a god named Nightfall, but it would have to be a real god.

As for a vote on these two awsome games, I can't see how to combine them into one game, they are way too different.

My vote goes for AU by a slight margin just because its easier for me to get players to play that than Midnight. AND...the new races and classes.

I do like midnight's magic system more, and I do like the world aspects of roleplaying possibilities more, and the heroic paths...

But I still side with AU. Man this is a hard one to vote for, for me at least.

Now, how about adding magic paths to AU? Wouldn't that be cool?

 

[Nightfall]

Trust me. Some day in Midnight lore, along side a sage named Ash Baylen, the god Nightfall, patron of rogues, bardic lore, and occasional mischief, will rise!

 

[rook111]

Thanks for all the input after reading what you guys had to say and consulting with the players I decided to go with the AU setting.
I appriciate all the help.

 

[Nightfall]

I tried Ash! Honest I did! But in any case Rook, enjoy. I know I am.

 

[Zogg]

Yippee! Glad to hear we've got another AU recruit! Not to badmouth Midnight, I really know nothing about the setting, but you will love AU!

Edit: corrected "no nothing" to "know nothing". I really drank too much sangria on Labor Day!

 

[Nightfall]

Well I'm glad Zogg is happy...maybe.

 

[Ashrem Bayle]

Well... you can lead a horse to water...