Obi-Wan Kenobi (spoilers)


log in or register to remove this ad

final scene-great loved it. Would love more of that if it comes back. Pay that person as you have the money

the rest of the episode was garbage

the power surge -really? it was a cool fight if it had ended in a different way. It carries over to the conversation vader has after the battle. He lost/no big deal that a jedi general is still out there and is alive. the emperor would not be so casual about this loss

the redemption of a dark side character to a light side. she has been trained her entire childhood for this. has no problem torturing the princess and cant forgive herself over a boy she has never met. Not buying the whole concept . reva leaving the lars family alive. Doesnt really fit with her character

Meeting Ben/being chased by a lightsaber character-seems to me this sort of destroys lore. hes not blind as he runs through the canyon. this is an event that would shape the whole family including luke

the shuttle craft getting there after the battle almost in time to save the day.

probably the worst story they have written so far filled with horrible acting and poor directing

Other than a few moments i would argue that the Solo movie is superior in every way

This franchise is basically alive due to mandalorian and some cartoons
 

final scene-great loved it. Would love more of that if it comes back. Pay that person as you have the money

the rest of the episode was garbage

the power surge -really? it was a cool fight if it had ended in a different way. It carries over to the conversation vader has after the battle. He lost/no big deal that a jedi general is still out there and is alive. the emperor would not be so casual about this loss

the redemption of a dark side character to a light side. she has been trained her entire childhood for this. has no problem torturing the princess and cant forgive herself over a boy she has never met. Not buying the whole concept . reva leaving the lars family alive. Doesnt really fit with her character

Meeting Ben/being chased by a lightsaber character-seems to me this sort of destroys lore. hes not blind as he runs through the canyon. this is an event that would shape the whole family including luke

the shuttle craft getting there after the battle almost in time to save the day.

probably the worst story they have written so far filled with horrible acting and poor directing

Other than a few moments i would argue that the Solo movie is superior in every way

This franchise is basically alive due to mandalorian and some cartoons
They were pretty careful with Luke. His head was out the hatch and he never saw Reva in the compound. He was above and in front of her on the ridge, then unconscious when she walked up to him.
 

so we are going to argue that leia remembers her meeting with ben but Luke will block it all out. I think Luke would at least have recognition and maybe ponder why the sandperson had that red light that was chasing him

hes 10? not 5-
 

so we are going to argue that leia remembers her meeting with ben but Luke will block it all out. I think Luke would at least have recognition and maybe ponder why the sandperson had that red light that was chasing him

hes 10? not 5-
Well, to be fair, he did say, "I wonder if she means old Ben Kenobi" after seeing Leia's vid, and Kenobi has had a full body transplant by then.
 

the redemption of a dark side character to a light side. she has been trained her entire childhood for this. has no problem torturing the princess and cant forgive herself over a boy she has never met. Not buying the whole concept . reva leaving the lars family alive. Doesnt really fit with her character
If she had no problem with torturing Leia, it's funny that she left it to an absolute last resort after trying everything else. And she never actually does it.
so we are going to argue that leia remembers her meeting with ben but Luke will block it all out. I think Luke would at least have recognition and maybe ponder why the sandperson had that red light that was chasing him

hes 10? not 5-
She had extinguished her lightsaber by the time she started chasing him across the desert, and didn't light it again until he was unconscious. All he knows is that some unidentified figure chased him in the dark.

And Luke doesn't have anything to block out when it comes to meeting Ben. He's not friends with him or anything in A New Hope, but he knows him and recognises him on sight.
 

I think it was overall emotionally satisfying.
But the space chase scene was as bad as it was in TLJ. They could have at least put Vader in a smaller ship (like an Arquitans or what it's called) or something that it seems plausible that his ship maybe can't destroy a freighter - or drop ship - that's flying in front of them.

The Emperor's response to Vader's failure seemed also rather light. Maybe Vader lied when he said the Emperor was not as forgiving as him.
 


I think it was overall emotionally satisfying.
But the space chase scene was as bad as it was in TLJ. They could have at least put Vader in a smaller ship (like an Arquitans or what it's called) or something that it seems plausible that his ship maybe can't destroy a freighter - or drop ship - that's flying in front of them.
The chase was rather ridiculous. This is an Imperial II class Star Destroyer, it has entire squadrons of TIE Fighters it can deploy in pursuit of a vessel that's currently incapable of going to lightspeed - it's not an either-or proposition between the two ships.

I think that's really why the Emperor calls Vader off in the end - he's demonstrating a clear lack of objectivity and clarity in his pursuit, and allowing him to continue it might give him some wrong ideas.
 

Very satisfying lightsaber duel. But, just like in Revenge of the Sith, I think it would have ended better with Vader's scene.

(Seriously, if RotS had ended with the POV of the mask descending on Vader's face, it would have changed the whole tone of the movie - and made A New Hope a much better title for its sequel.)
 

Trending content

Remove ads

Top