Comment #1:
Domination is not as powerful an effect as you might think. Ki'Willis will get another saving throw if Klaxeon asks her to do anything against her nature. If she is asked to do anything self-destructive, she automatically passes the new saving throw. Ki'Willis already knew that Quertus might be under the control of the coin and might have to be restrained until the curse could be removed. Ki'Willis was already thinking about giving Klaxeon the coin in exchange for the Cephalometer.
Conclusion, Klaxeon has not yet violated Ki'Willis's nature, although he is taking things rather than trading for them.
Comment #2: Can Ki'Willis feel the difference between a mind probe and a domination. Definitely not for magic resistance purposes. For the will save, the two effects are so close that Ki'Willis can't tell the difference.
Comment #3: Yes, Klaxeon has all of the appropriate feats to avoid psychic displays.
Comment #4: Klaxeon has a +27 bluff check and he has a psychic power called conceal thoughts that adds another +20 to his bluff check as a competence bonus and nullifies "detect lies" and similar spells. And he has some other mental stuff. So you are talking about someone with a +47 (or more) bonus to his bluff check. Klaxeon has fooled lots of people before now.
Actually, it seems much worse than it really is.
1) Klaxeon's henchmen is dying.
2) You were thinking about trading the coin for the cephalometer anyways, and the cephalomoter is on the ground next to the dying mindflayer
3) You didn't let the bugbear be dominated, which means that Kilcif is not an enemy right now (Klaxeon's original plan was to dominate Kilcif and feeblemind Krecil).
4) Klaxeon has revealed to you that he plans to plane shift on the next round. And you'll be free of mental control once he is no longer on the plane.
5) And if Klaxeon is lying and he doesn't plane shift, I'm going to give Ki'Willis another saving throw because submission is innately against her nature (as your post in the playing thread made clear). Krecil does not get another saving throw, since he is used to being bossed around.
Serpenteye said:
Wouldn't Ki'willis feel the difference between a Mind Probe and a Domination? She relinquished her save for one but not the other. Could Klaxeon manifest a Domination without tell-tale displays? How could I have been this stupid?